:LRC wrote:
"Take that everyone who thought I wasn't going to be back. ... Whenever you have any bump in the road, whether it's two weeks or two years, there are so many naysayers. … Let it fuel you. Don't take it personally. Go out and prove them wrong."
- Jennifer Simpson talking to the Colorado Springs Gazette after completing the mile/3,000 double at 2011 USA indoor meet.
As fans, LetsRun.com is certainly excited to see Simpson, who is one of just five American women to ever have broken 4:00 for 1,500, to be back racing at a high level. However, doubling up on a watered-down field at USAs doesn't prove to us that she's back in a big in a world-class way.
The real news at USAs would have been if Simpson hadn't completed the double. The fact of the matter is in the 3,000, not a single woman had a PR within 10 seconds of Simpson, and in the mile, only two women in the final at USAs had a PR within 10 seconds of Simpson's, with the closest being 8.65 seconds slower.
3,000 PRs Of 3k Finalists At USAs
(Runners listed in order of finish at USAs)
1. Jenny Simpson New Balance 8:42.03
2. Sara Hall Asics 8:52.35
3. Allie Kieffer Sun Elite 9:08.13
4. Mindy Sullivan unattached 9:25.73
5. Stephanie Pezzullo unattached 9:19.00
6. Erin Dromgoole New Balance Boston 9:18.71
1,500 PRs Of Mile Finalists At USAs
(Runners listed in order of finish at USAs)
1. Jenny Simpson, New Balance, 3:59.90
2. Heidi Dahl, New Balance, 4:09.75
3. Gabriele Anderson, TmUSA Mn/Brooks, 4:12.06
4. Sara Hall, Asics, 4:08.55
5. Lauren Bonds, adidas Raleigh Track Club, 4:14.29
6, Karly Hamric, RIADHA, 4:13.54
7. Frances Koons, New Balance, 4:12.6h
8. Annick Lamar, NYAC, 4:21.38
Imagine if we'd started this section by telling you that a 4:17/9:22 high school boy was racing a 4:25/9:30 high school boy in a 3,000, you'd certainly expect the 4:17/9:22 boy to win nearly every single time, as he's got a better 3,200 time and is way faster at the mile as well. Well, that's exactly what the matchup between Simpson and Sara Hall was like in the 3,000. If that same runner came back the next day and won the 1,600 against a field that included no one with a PR faster than 4:25, you wouldn't be amazed.
Our point? It's great to see Simpson back in good form and it's even better that she didn't just blow off USAs like so many top pros, but her double doesn't yet prove she's truly back at world-class level.
However, the real question might be, "Who thought Jenny wouldn't be back?" As message board poster edumacator said, "Even on this site, where everyone loves to declare an athlete 'done' after a couple bad races, I don't recall a log of people saying Barringer/Simpson was never going to be back. I mean she's what, 23? Why would she not get back?"