What data? Do you have them? Even a list of names?
I think you are just playing make believe. I think you are using "data" as a rhetorical device to convince us that opinions are special, and should be given more authority than then opinions of other fans.
You can give us a list of all of the high school phenoms over the past 5? 10? 20? years, right?
If you can't, then you are just another fan who has an opinion.