800 dude wrote:
NERunner053 wrote:
Seidel hasn't done much since college but then ran a solid Manchester RR, RNR San Antonion, & Houston Half. None of that was enough to think she would come into her first marathon and take down Hall/Hasay/Sisson/Huddle/Bates/Taylor/etc.
Sure it was. When one of the most talented American runners of her generation is healthy and putting up solid times, you'd be silly to discount her. The only people in that list with her ceiling are Hasay and Sisson. Hasay was obviously a big question mark going in. I don't include Huddle in that group because she's been doing the marathon for long enough that there's no reason to expect she'll ever put it together.
Hindsight is 2020. If you had surveyed 10,000 people who follow American distance running one week ago, maybe 10 would have picked her for the team. And that 10 would have included Molly, her coach, her sister and one of her fellow baristas. It's an amazing and unlikely story that makes us celebrate the one-shot, top-3 U.S. trials system. No disrespect to Molly, who was a talented college runner to be sure. We can all recognize her now as one of the next generation of great American marathoners. I'm just saying it wasn't obvious before the race, and it's disingenuous to claim otherwise.