Jzargo wrote:
Rojo, did she ever get back to you with a coherent counter argument, or was it pretty much limited to name calling?
1) Let me start by saying that it's come to my attention that a number of you have been speculating as to the journalist in question. Please stop. None of you have guessed the correct person. I've removed some of the guesses due to complaints.
2) I heard from the editor this morning and she let it be known that they have killed the story. It appears that they didn't feel the author was giving us a fair shake.
I had reached out to the editor via email to let her know that I vehemently denied the accusation that I was leading a "bigoted" conversation regarding Caster Semenya that is full of "fearmongering". I explained to the editor that the author had said I was the one responsible for deaths and was the one fearmongering. I also told the editor the author had declined to a Q&A or podcast being done that would feature one of her hand-selected scientists whom she viewed to have the right answer as compared to Ross Tucker and Joanna Harper. I told the editor this and also volunteered to write a rebuttal article that they could have free of charge.
The editor was unaware of the freelancers past extensive interactions with letsrun.com and thus killed the story which was going to focus on or portrayal of Semenya. In my mind, it's clear the editor realized the author had an agenda to grind and wasn't out for the truth.