Which sport has the smallest performance gap when accounting for gender?
Swimming?
Ultrarunning?
Other?
Which sport has the smallest performance gap when accounting for gender?
Swimming?
Ultrarunning?
Other?
I think soccer might have a somewhat narrow performance gap. The women's skills are just as good as the men's, so the only difference is going to be speed. Speed of course is important, so the men would beat the women consistently at the top levels, but the women wouldn't make it easy, they would be able to legitimately play against the men I think as long as they kept it a controlled passing game.
peter griffin's underpants wrote:
Which sport has the smallest performance gap when accounting for gender?
Swimming?
Ultrarunning?
Other?
If there is such a thing as ultra swimming, that would probably be your answer. Pretty sure I've read that the further the distance in ultra running the smaller the gap gets. I would think this would apply to swimming even more given women's naturally higher body fat.
But what do I know?
Reggi Nytrid wrote:
LOL, no. The U.S. women's soccer team would probably lose to a boys' high school team. Not even close.
Germanys female national soccer team played the Under 17 boys team of a local club in Stuttgart a few years back and lost 3-0, and Germanys team is always ranked top 3 in the world.
The US, German or Brazilian team, when playing their male counterpart, would lose anywhere between 15-0 and 20-0.
The gap is HUGE in soccer. Much, much bigger than in T&F where it's about 10%.
Twerking.
joho wrote:
peter griffin's underpants wrote:Which sport has the smallest performance gap when accounting for gender?
Swimming?
Ultrarunning?
Other?
If there is such a thing as ultra swimming, that would probably be your answer. Pretty sure I've read that the further the distance in ultra running the smaller the gap gets. I would think this would apply to swimming even more given women's naturally higher body fat.
But what do I know?
That's more of a participation issue. Not a gender issue.
Maybe lumberjack contests?"
Lumberjack World Championship
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
The Lumberjack World Championships are held annually in Hayward, Wisconsin. The event began in 1960 and is held at the Lumberjack Bowl. There are 21 events for both men and women to compete for over $50,000 in prize money. Contestants come from the United States, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. The events include sawing, chopping, logrolling, and climbing to test the strength and agility of over 100 competitors.
Competition venue
Contents
[hide] 1 Women's events 1.1 Women's single buck
1.2 Women's underhand chop
1.3 Women's logrolling
1.4 Women's boom run
2 Men's events 2.1 Underhand block chop
2.2 Standing block chop
2.3 Springboard chop
2.4 Single buck
2.5 Hot saw
2.6 60-foot speed climb
2.7 90-foot speed climb
2.8 Logrolling (birling)
2.9 Boom run
3 Team events 3.1 Jack and Jill
3.2 Double buck
3.3 Team relay
4 Awards 4.1 All-Around Lady Jill
4.2 Tony Wise All-Around Champion
5 Sponsors
6 See also
7 External links
Women's events[edit source]
Women's single buck[edit source]
Competitors saw through a 16-inch-diameter (410 mm) white pine log for the fastest time. A starting cut arc is allowed in the competition. Timing begins when the signal "GO" is called and ends when the log is completely severed. The world record with a time of 11.61 seconds was set in 2006 by Nancy Zalewski.
Women's underhand chop[edit source]
Using a single bit pinned ax, competitors chop through a horizontal aspen log, 11 inches (280 mm) in diameter, and 15–28 inches (380–710 mm) long, for the fastest time. Nancy Zalewski set a new world record in 2009 with a time of 29.24 seconds.
Women's logrolling[edit source]
Opponents step onto a floating log, cuff it to start the roll, spin it rapidly in the water with their feet, stop or snub it suddenly by digging into the log with special caulked birling shoes and a reverse motion to maneuver their adversaries off balance and into the water, a feat called 'wetting'. Dislodging an opponent constitutes a fall. The cardinal rule of logrolling is 'never take your eyes off your opponent's feet'. The referee starts each match. Competing birlers step off a dock onto a floating log, grasping pike poles held by attendants for balance. As they push off from the dock, the referee instructs the birlers to steady the log. When he is certain both birlers have equal control, he says, 'Throw your poles'. The match is on and continues to a fall or to expiration of the time limit set for each log. When the time limit is reached, the same match continues onto the next smaller log. In the semi-finals and the finals, the contest is decided by the best three out of five falls. Women start on 14-inch (360 mm) logs. In 2003 Tina Bosworth set a new world record of 10 wins.
Women's boom run[edit source]
Starting on the log-rolling dock, two competitors run head to head on adjacent booms. Each competitor must step off the logrolling dock, running across a chain of logrolling logs to the chopping dock, circling a specified competition station and cross the pond on the boom logs back to the logrolling dock. The competitor must step onto the logrolling dock and touch the starting point. This is a timed event and is timed to the tenths of a second. Anyone leaving before the word "go" will be accessed a 10-second penalty.
Men's events[edit source]
Underhand block chop[edit source]
Using a five-pound single-bit axe, competitors chop through a vertical standing aspen log 12-inch (300 mm)es in diameter and 28-inch (710 mm)es long. Timing begins on the signal "go" and ends when the log is severed. A new world record was set in 2006 by Jason Wynyard with a time of 15.94. In 2007, competitors moved from the underhand chop to the standing block chop for one continuous timed event known as the endurance event.
Standing block chop[edit source]
Using a five-pound single-bit axe, competitors chop through a vertical standing aspen log 12-inch (300 mm)es in diameter and 28-inch (710 mm)es long. Timing begins on the "go" signal and ends when the log is severed. This event was combined with the men's underhand chop as the endurance or combination event in 2007. Competitors moved from the underhand chop to the standing block chop for one continuous timed event. The world record for the standing block chop is held by Jason Wynyard set in 1998 with a time of 18.33.
Springboard chop[edit source]
This event combines the skills of the chopper and the high climber. Out in the forest this technique enables a working lumberjack to reach softer wood above the tough and knotty base of a tree marked for cutting. Contestants climb a height of nine feet using two springboard placements and chop through a 12-inch-diameter (300 mm) aspen log mounted on the top of the spar pole. Dave Bolstad set a new world record of 41.15 in 2003 besting his previous world record time of 41.63 in 2001.
Single buck[edit source]
A single sawyer uses a one-man bucking saw to cut through a 20-inch-diameter (510 mm) white pine log for the best time. Dion Lane set a new world record in 2006 with a time of 10.78 seconds.
Hot saw[edit source]
A single sawyer using a single-cylinder, single-motor power saw makes three vertical cuts—down, up and down—through a 20-inch-diameter (510 mm) white pine log. This one-man contest is strictly against time. Chain saws may be warmed up prior to the contest, but must be turned off before the contest begins. Neither self-starting nor impulse-type push button starters nor twin motors are allowed. A starter gives the countdown and on the signal "go", competitors start their saws and make the three cuts. The contest ends when the third slice is severed. All cuts must be complete. Dave Bolstad of New Zealand holds the world record with a time of 5.55 seconds set in 2007.
Speed climbing
60-foot speed climb[edit source]
Competitor scales a 60-foot-tall (18 m) cedar spar pole and returns to the ground. Contestants perform on twin spar poles and they must climb within 240 degrees of the sparring pole, as marked. Event is strictly against time and begins when the signal "go" is given and ends when the contestant touches the ground after climbing to the 60-foot mark. At the starting signal, contestants must have one foot on the ground and the other foot below the orange line as marked on the sparring pole. The contestant must touch the pole every 15 feet on the descent. The two climbers use spurred climbers and steel-core climbing ropes to scale the spar poles. Only traditional spurs are allowed. Brian Bartow of Grants Pass, Oregon holds the world record of 12.33 seconds in this event.
90-foot speed climb[edit source]
Contestant scales an 90-foot-tall (27 m) cedar spar pole and returns to the ground against time. Contestants compete on twin spar poles. Contestant must climb within the front 240 degrees of the sparring pole, as marked. Timing begins on the signal "go" and ends when the contestant touches the ground after ringing one of the two bells on top of the spar pole. At the starting signal, contestants must have one foot on the ground and the other foot below the orange line as marked on the sparring pole. On the descent climbers are required to touch inside each section. Contestants use spurred climbers and steel-core climbing ropes to scale the spar poles. In this climb Brian Bartow of Oregon holds the world record with a time of 19.87 set in 2006.
Logrolling (birling)[edit source]
In competition opponents step onto a floating log, cuff it to start the roll, spin it rapidly in the water with their feet, stop or snub it suddenly by digging into the log with special caulked birling shoes and a reverse motion to maneuver their adversaries off balance and into the water, a feat called 'wetting'. Dislodging an opponent constitutes a fall. The cardinal rule of logrolling is 'never take your eyes off your opponent's feet'. The referee starts each match. Competing birlers step off a dock onto a floating log, grasping pike poles held by attendants for balance. As they push off from the dock, the referee instructs the birlers to steady the log. When he is certain both birlers have equal control, he says, 'Throw your poles'. The match is on and continues to a fall or to expiration of the time limit set for each log. When the time limit is reached, the same match continues onto the next smaller log. In the semi-finals and the finals, the contest is decided by the best three out of five falls. Men start on 15-inch (380 mm) logs.
Boom run[edit source]
Starting on the log-rolling dock, two competitors run head to head on adjacent booms. Each competitor must step off the logrolling dock, running across a chain of logrolling logs to the chopping dock, circling a specified competition station and cross the pond on the boom logs back to the logrolling dock. The competitor must step onto the logrolling dock and touch the starting point. This is a timed event and is timed to the tenths of a second. Anyone leaving before the word "go" will be accessed a 10-second penalty.
Team events[edit source]
Jack and Jill competition
Jack and Jill[edit source]
A bucking contests where a man and woman compete for the best time to cut through a 20-inch (510 mm) white pine log. Starting cuts of no more than 1⁄2-inch (13 mm) deep, in order to set the teeth of the saw, are allowed. Timing starts on the signal "go" and ends when the block is severed. Logs must be cut completely through. The world record for this event was set in 2005 by Jason and Karmyn Wynyard with a time of 6.17 seconds.
Double buck[edit source]
Two sawyers working as a team use a two-man bucking saw to cut through a 20-inch-diameter (510 mm) white pine log. Double buck team consists of two men. A starting cut arc is allowed. Timing begins for both competitions when the signal to "go" is called, and ends when the log is completely severed. Jason Wynyard and Dion Lane hold the world record with a time of 4.77 seconds set in 2005.
Team relay[edit source]
In this timed event there are two teams competing. Each team consist of a 60-foot climber, 2 boom runners (1 male, 1 female), a hot sawyer, a women's single buck sawyer and a standing block chopper. First a climber must climb and descend the 60-foot pole, when their feet touch the pad it is the signal for the male boom runner stationed on the chopping dock to run the logs to the logrolling dock; when he touches the dock it is then the female boom runner's turn to run the logs over to the chopping dock, once touching there the hot saws then cut through a 20-inch (510 mm) log and when the log drops the women commence the single buck, with the standing block chop the anchor event in this relay. Whichever team finishes first with the best time is the winner of the event. This event is the combination of the best of all the lumberjack skills: power, strength and sheer determination.
Awards[edit source]
All-Around Lady Jill[edit source]
The All-Around Lady Jill Champion is awarded each year to the Lumber Jill who scores the most points. The key to the All-Around title is endurance and the ability to compete in as many events as possible. The top contestants in every event receive points each day of the competition, making it important to make it through early qualifying rounds in as many events as possible. Points are given each day for the top six places in each event, with a first place being awarded 6 points, second 5 points and so on. Logrollers will receive triple points for their final placement. This is because the final standings are the only opportunity for logrollers to earn points. Women's All-Around events are the underhand chop, single buck, Jack and Jill, logrolling and the boom run. The 2009 winner was Nancy Zalewski of Wisconsin, who has now taken home the crown five times.
Tony Wise All-Around Champion[edit source]
The Tony Wise All-Around Champion, named after the founder of the Lumberjack World Championships, is awarded each year to the lumberjack who scores the most points. The key to the All-Around title is endurance and the ability to compete in as many events as possible. The top contestants in every event receive points each day of competition, making it important to make it through early qualifying rounds in as many events as possible. Points are given each day for the top six places in each event, with a first place being awarded 6 points, second 5 points and so on. There are two exceptions to this. Due to the nature of the springboard chop and logrolling, the all-around points for these two events will be scored differently. For the springboard, the sixth fastest competitors from Friday's and Saturday's heats receive double the points. This is because springboard competitors only get one opportunity to earn all-around points. 5th and 6th placements are awarded triple points for their final placement. This is because the final standings are the only opportunity for logrollers to earn points. The Tony Wise All-Around events are: underhand chop, standing chop, springboard chop, double buck, single buck, hot saw, Jack & Jill, logrolling, boom run, 60-foot climb and 90-foot climb. Jason Wynyard, who was the 2009 winner, has taken home the crown for 11 years in a row.
doesn't the marathon have the least percentage gap between men's and women's world records, in running events? after that would be the 100m.
It's almost certainly one of:
a) open-water swimming where body fat makes you both buoyant and warm
b) ski-jumping where technique is literally all that matters
In almost every other sport or event, the lack of speed, lack of strength or high % body fat is too detrimental to overcome. Also, in many sports the (more) dramatic changes women undergo through puberty means they have to relearn everything - a significant disadvantage in technique sports.
Personal opinion, I've always been surprised women aren't better at golf. The fact that Michelle Wie can drive a ball nearly as far as Tiger demonstrates driving distance is largely dependent on technique. From the second shot on, iron play and the short game are as well. I mean, maybe Tiger gets to hit a 52 degree while Michelle needs an 8-iron but it seems that could be overcome with practice. There are probably social issues preventing women from keeping pace.
the gentler sex wrote:
b) ski-jumping where technique is literally all that matters
Ski jumping can not be compared because they have a longer approach to make up for their lack of weight.
It's like giving a female race car driver a bigger engine.
the gentler sex wrote:
It's almost certainly one of:
.
Personal opinion, I've always been surprised women aren't better at golf. The fact that Michelle Wie can drive a ball nearly as far as Tiger demonstrates driving distance is largely dependent on technique. From the second shot on, iron play and the short game are as well. I mean, maybe Tiger gets to hit a 52 degree while Michelle needs an 8-iron but it seems that could be overcome with practice. There are probably social issues preventing women from keeping pace.
Golf is not a sport. Might as well have written tiddlywinks.
I suppose the answer is either horse or auto racing- if you consider them to be sports, that is.