I bow to your superior intellect and reasoning skills.
Since I'm an idiot, please remind me how many HOF votes Bo received for football and baseball?
By your reasoning, I assume you've already placed CJ Spiller in the running back pantheon. (5.5 YPC). And perhaps RGIII and Cam Newton should retire now to keep their #1 and # 2 slot on the all-time team vs. Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Joe Montana.
And, gosh, Ralph Sampson was awesome wasn't he? I heard he was really tall and if scored for 15 years like he did in that one game, he'd be in HOF too.
And, remember that shot Keith Smart made? Man, the Bulls should've picked him up instead of that guy from UNC.
Or, maybe more to the point.... you probably rate Anna Nicole Smith as the greatest actress ever.... she was really 'talented'
I apologize for my stupidity of rating players based on their actual performance vs. how they looked at the combine or on 30 seconds of highlight reel for 3 plays.