I know very little about the Dixie Chicks, so I have no opinion on them either way, but one thing I do know for sure is the RHCP epitomise the word 'mediocrity'. I listen to a lot of music, and their songs do nothing for me whatsoever. Seriously, it's all so predictable and mundane, and has been for years. I just don't get it at all.
As a Brit, I probably don't get to hear all the great American bands I'd like to, but I can think of at least 30 off the top of my head who are so far in advance of RHCP, it's not even funny. My Morning Jacket, Wilco, Flaming Lips, Bright Eyes, Grandaddy, Broken Social Scene (mybe Canadian, not sure), Band of Horses, Cat Power ..... all so far in advance of RHCP in terms of songwriting, it almost defies belief. Normally, with popular bands/songs, even if I don't like it, I can see the mass appeal, but RHCP... what am I missing? I just dont get it. Bit like Adam Sandler. When has that guy 'ever' been remotely funny?