raced against CU
Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 5:57PM Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Did anyone see the track and field news rankings?

1500 METERS
1. Aslı Çakır Alptekin (Turkey)
2. Abeba Aregawi (Ethiopia)
3. Maryam Jamal (Bahrain)
4. Genzebe Dibaba (Turkey)
5. Shannon Rowbury (USA)
6. Hellen Obiri (Kenya)
7. Gamze Bulut (Turkey)
8. Morgan Uceny (USA)
9. Viola Kibiwott (Kenya)
10. Jenny Simpson (USA)

http://www.trackandfieldnews.com/images/stories/Rankings/2012worldw.pdf

Simpson #10. How can that be? Yes as world champ she got basically to run in every big race of the year and thus had some 'finishes' but i bet the following 34 girls are upset as she was #35 on US list:

1 03:56.1 Mariem Alaoui Selsouli 6-Jul
2 03:56.5 Abeba Aregawi 31-May
3 03:56.6 Aslı Çakır Alptekin 6-Jul
4 03:57.8 Genzebe Dibaba 19-May
5 03:59.2 Viola Kibiwott 6-Jul
6 03:59.3 Yekaterina Kostetskaya 6-Jul
7 03:59.5 Yekaterina Martynova 6-Jul
8 03:59.6 Svetlana Podosyonova 13-Jun
9 03:59.6 Btissam Lakhouad 6-Jul
10 03:59.7 Hellen Obiri 31-May
11 03:59.7 Tatyana Tomashova 6-Jul
12 03:59.9 Yekaterina Gorbunova 13-Jun
13 04:00.1 Yelena Soboleva 6-Jul
14 04:00.1 Yekaterina Poistogova 17-Jun
15 04:00.5 Kristina Khaleyeva 13-Jun
16 04:00.8 Yelena Arzhakova 13-Jun
17 04:01.2 Anna Mishchenko 6-Jul
18 04:01.2 Gamze Bulut 8-Aug
19 04:01.2 Maryam Jamal 17-Aug
20 04:01.6 Morgan Uceny 31-May
21 04:01.7 Yuliya Zaripova 5-Jul
22 04:01.7 Mimi Belete 17-Aug
23 04:01.8 Natalya Yevdokimova 6-Jul
24 04:02.1 Lisa Dobriskey 6-Jul
25 04:02.3 Yuliya Chizhenko 19-Jun
26 04:02.4 Natallia Kareiva 8-Aug
27 04:02.6 Siham Hilali 6-Jul
28 04:03.0 Laura Weightman 8-Aug
29 04:03.0 Lucia Klocová 8-Aug
30 04:03.1 Shannon Rowbury 17-Aug
31 04:03.2 Mary Kuria 4-Sep
32 04:03.7 Ingvill Måkestad Bovim 6-Jul
33 04:03.8 Faith Kipyegon 19-May
34 04:04.1 Hannah England 27-May
alfredmorris
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 6:10PM - in reply to raced against CU Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
I don't understand what your list of 34 names and times is about. Please explain further...I'm stupid.
www
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 6:18PM - in reply to alfredmorris Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

alfredmorris wrote:

I don't understand what your list of 34 names and times is about. Please explain further...I'm stupid.


Those were the 34 women that ran faster than Simpson last year. But at least 1 tested positive.
alfredmorris
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 6:21PM - in reply to www Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Okay, but wouldn't that make her #35 on the world list and not #35 on the US list? And those funny sounding names aren't Americans. OP screwed up somewhere.
Noter of things
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 6:34PM - in reply to raced against CU Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
That settles it. I'm naming my daughter Yekaterina. Should get her right around 4 for the 1500.
Time is meaningless
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 6:40PM - in reply to Noter of things Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Who cares about time? That's the least important factor in the rankings.

It's easy to criticize the rankings. It's not as easy to make a case for who deserves to be ranked ahead of her. Please do so.
pedro sanchez
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 7:02PM - in reply to raced against CU Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
there are 3 Americans in the top 10. That's all that matters your point is irrelevant.
coach d
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 7:09PM - in reply to pedro sanchez Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
BTW Aregawi is now a citizen of SWEDEN, by nature of marriage.

No kidding.
vghojbnjk
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 7:10PM - in reply to Time is meaningless Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

Time is meaningless wrote:

Who cares about time? That's the least important factor in the rankings.

It's easy to criticize the rankings. It's not as easy to make a case for who deserves to be ranked ahead of her. Please do so.


Yekaterina Kostetskaya who won the Russian champs and made the Olympic final.

Tatyana Tomashova who came third in the Russian champs and fourth in the Olympic final.

Now, please tell me which brilliant races Jenny Simpson ran that justify her top 10 ranking despite having average times for the year?
pispass
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 8:16PM - in reply to Noter of things Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

Noter of things wrote:

That settles it. I'm naming my daughter Yekaterina. Should get her right around 4 for the 1500.


Just make sure she is comfortable trading p!ss with a nonrunner to pass the testing.
Les
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 10:10PM - in reply to raced against CU Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
The rankings look about right to me. If anything, Simpson's ranked too high. Remember, last year after winning the World Championships she was ranked 3rd. Rankings are about SEASON records. 1) Honors won, 2) head to head competition. Marks count for little in the rankings.
Wossamotta
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 12/31/2012 11:48PM - in reply to Les Reply | Return to Index | Report Post
Genzebe Dibaba is not from Turkey
vghojbnjk
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 1/1/2013 3:57AM - in reply to Les Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

Les wrote:

The rankings look about right to me. If anything, Simpson's ranked too high.


Sigh...
Time is meaningless
RE: Jenny Simpson World Ranked #10 for 2012? Really? 1/1/2013 10:21PM - in reply to vghojbnjk Reply | Return to Index | Report Post

vghojbnjk wrote:


Time is meaningless wrote:

Who cares about time? That's the least important factor in the rankings.

It's easy to criticize the rankings. It's not as easy to make a case for who deserves to be ranked ahead of her. Please do so.


Yekaterina Kostetskaya who won the Russian champs and made the Olympic final.

Tatyana Tomashova who came third in the Russian champs and fourth in the Olympic final.

Now, please tell me which brilliant races Jenny Simpson ran that justify her top 10 ranking despite having average times for the year?


Kostetskaya only ran the 1500 in 3 meets: Moscow Champs, Russian Champs and Olympics. Too thin of a record.

Same with Tomashova; just replace the Kuts meet for the Moscow Champs.