Does not follow instructions.
One of the classic behaviors of lestsrun. Thread starter asks a "what is the best (topic)?" question. After four of five posts thread contributors change the question to "name as many (topics) as randomly flow into your consciousness?"
Since almost no one actually thinks their contribution answers the question of 'best song about NYC', I will channel my best Alex Trebek for my contribution to the question that was not actually asked:
Alex: "The answer is, New York Telephone Conversation"
Letsrun Jeopardy contestant "What is the shortest song about New York City, Alex?"
FWIW, just about every Lou Reed song was about New York City. Billy Joel too.