I went to Wabash for a year before transferring to another DIII liberal arts college.
Wabash is a great school. My professors were fantastic. The school's reputation in Indiana and regionally is really strong. Programs are really rigorous and guys tend to be competitive about grades (I think the social vacuum contributes to this). When I transferred (to a school that is rated consistently higher than Wabash), the study habits I had picked up at Wabash made me one of the hardest working students at my new school. At least when I was there, Wabash was freakishly competitive, academically.
The social situation was just awful (for me) and is the reason I transferred. Sure, some of the frats have arrangements with sororities at Purdue and other schools, but girls do not flock to campus. In my experience, they did whatever the opposite of "flock to campus" is. They cme to our parties because they had to, and the girls that came were the sororities' "C team" and couldn't wait to leave.
Crawfordsville doesn't provide any sort of social scene, either.
It was miserable.
That said, the guys who were from Indy and already had lots of friends at nearby schools managed OK. They worked hard during the week and then took off to socialize with their friends on the weekend. I was from out of state.
Great school. Great (local/regional) reputation. Awesome profs. Miserable social scene that's borderline psychologically unhealthy, in my opinion. Not much diversity--I am a Midwestern white guy, and wanted to be exposed to something other than the Midwestern white guy perspective in and out of the classroom.
Some guys made it work, and the few classmates I kept in contact with are wildly successful.
Take a visit and check it out. You know what you want out of your college experience and maybe Wabash can deliver for you. I couldn't get out of Crawfordsville fast enough.