1.)low barrier to entry trying to flex they are the same as the elite level cross fitters. doing high volume reps on compound lifts meant to be power lifts, with bad form and no 2.)baseline athleticism. 3.) a little bit like pickle ball in the sense that it prob started off as a suburban white collar hobby and its all cute until real elitists from ALL ethnicities start to play
This is objectively false. Ashton Eaton's 100- 10.20, 400-45.00, 110H- 13.35, and LJ- 27'-O" were actual or borderline D1 All American/ US National Trial Marks.
In terms of the 1500, most, if not all, CrossFit Games finalists would struggle to break 5:00 for 1500.
Again, you're just bashing cross-fitters without knowing anything about cross-fitters.
Laura Horvath won the cross-fit games last year. She ran the cross-country 5k in 19:02. On a track she could easily run a sub 5 1500.
She's also stronger than Eaton.
Jeffrey Adler won the cross-fit games last year. He ran the cross-country 5k in 16:46. On a track he could easily run a sub 4:30 1500.
He's also much much stronger than Eaton.
That 2023 Crosfit Games 5k xc course was not 5k.
You can compare the race video to Google Earth and the course loop comes out to about .93 miles/1500 meters which gives you a race distance of 4.5k for 3 loops. Seems like you need to add about 2 minutes to those 5k times.
When was the last time you went for a run?Day 3 of the 2023 CrossFit Games began with a run for time. Watch the men and women push the pace in Test 7.Cross-C...
Again, you're just bashing cross-fitters without knowing anything about cross-fitters.
Laura Horvath won the cross-fit games last year. She ran the cross-country 5k in 19:02. On a track she could easily run a sub 5 1500.
She's also stronger than Eaton.
Jeffrey Adler won the cross-fit games last year. He ran the cross-country 5k in 16:46. On a track he could easily run a sub 4:30 1500.
He's also much much stronger than Eaton.
That 2023 Crosfit Games 5k xc course was not 5k.
You can compare the race video to Google Earth and the course loop comes out to about .93 miles/1500 meters which gives you a race distance of 4.5k for 3 loops. Seems like you need to add about 2 minutes to those 5k times.
Again, you're just bashing cross-fitters without knowing anything about cross-fitters.
Laura Horvath won the cross-fit games last year. She ran the cross-country 5k in 19:02. On a track she could easily run a sub 5 1500.
She's also stronger than Eaton.
Jeffrey Adler won the cross-fit games last year. He ran the cross-country 5k in 16:46. On a track he could easily run a sub 4:30 1500.
He's also much much stronger than Eaton.
That 2023 Crosfit Games 5k xc course was not 5k.
You can compare the race video to Google Earth and the course loop comes out to about .93 miles/1500 meters which gives you a race distance of 4.5k for 3 loops. Seems like you need to add about 2 minutes to those 5k times.
One of the first events at the CrossFit Games this week is a basic 5k run on a cross-country course in Madison, WI. It's hilarious reading other posts where non-runners predict these CrossFitters will run 17:30 or faster on a...
This illustrates the worst tendencies of Crossfit hype.
Crossfit athletes do something that is respectable- Run a "5k" in an 18- 20 min equivalent time while weighing 180-200 lbs. Then instead of taking the performance for what it is, the organizers purposely misrepresent the distance to make the performances seem better than they were.
illustrates the worst tendencies of Crossfit hype.
Crossfit athletes do something that is respectable- Run a "5k" in an 18- 20 min equivalent time while weighing 180-200 lbs. Then instead of taking the performance for what it is, the organizers purposely misrepresent the distance to make the performances seem better than they were.
I think there is also a decent chance they just don’t care. Imagine if all their weights are also 10% light.
You can compare the race video to Google Earth and the course loop comes out to about .93 miles/1500 meters which gives you a race distance of 4.5k for 3 loops. Seems like you need to add about 2 minutes to those 5k times.
This illustrates the worst tendencies of Crossfit hype.
Crossfit athletes do something that is respectable- Run a "5k" in an 18- 20 min equivalent time while weighing 180-200 lbs. Then instead of taking the performance for what it is, the organizers purposely misrepresent the distance to make the performances seem better than they were.
That's horrible!
Not as bad as the Let's Run hobby joggers like yourself who run 25 minute 5ks and sh*t on anyone who doesn't run sub 13... but still horrible!
Because what they are recommending is very likely to lead to injury (improper stances, positioning and lifting too much weight) and they act like a cult when referring to it.
Why are they heavily ridiculed and discriminated against online when they have the best of both worlds? (strength + cardio) They literally have the most balanced physiques.
I have yet to see one "elite" crossfitter who is remotely speedy. I have immense respect for guys like throwers and heavyweight olympic lifters. I watched a 350lb thrower on my college team run a 29s 200m for fun. Watching crossfitters sprint is embarrassing, and I don't know how you can call yourself the greatest athlete if you can't run even kind of fast.
You’re so ignorant it’s actually kind of cute. These guys who “can’t run even kind of fast” would murk you in any sprint event:
Why are they heavily ridiculed and discriminated against online when they have the best of both worlds? (strength + cardio) They literally have the most balanced physiques.
Ashton Eaton's PR in the discus is 47.36m. The boys high school record is over 72m.
Ashton Eaton's PR in the shot put is 15.4m. The boys high school record is over 24m.
The dude isn't very strong and high school boys almost double his PR.
Imma take a wild guess those hs boys were 250+ lbs and 6'4"+, if not 6'6"+ 280+ lbs
Is that what your cross fitter in question looks like?
I must be being trolled here. 24m would be a world record. Crouser threw 23.56m. The HS shot is only 12 lbs. Ashton is throwing 16lbs. And he's tiny compared to a shot putter. HS discus is 1.6 kg. Olympic is 2 kg.
Ashton Eaton's PR in the discus is 47.36m. The boys high school record is over 72m.
Ashton Eaton's PR in the shot put is 15.4m. The boys high school record is over 24m.
The dude isn't very strong and high school boys almost double his PR.
Imma take a wild guess those hs boys were 250+ lbs and 6'4"+, if not 6'6"+ 280+ lbs
Is that what your cross fitter in question looks like?
I must be being trolled here. 24m would be a world record. Crouser threw 23.56m. The HS shot is only 12 lbs. Ashton is throwing 16lbs. And he's tiny compared to a shot putter. HS discus is 1.6 kg. Olympic is 2 kg.
Hopefully your point was cross fitters are dumb.
What does it matter how big they are?
The "dumb" person I was talking with was arguing that cross-fitters aren't even as fit as decathletes because decathletes are better at the decathlon than they are.
I was simply pointing out that decathletes are worse than high school boys at most events.
And for the 10th time being the "fittest athlete" does NOT mean being the best at every single discipline or event on earth.
I think we've proven pretty conclusively that the the anti-cross fit crowd are all morons who feel very threatened by anyone who's in better shape than them.
They're not really ridiculed, but at the same time they're not excellent at anything.
They are mediocre rowers, mediocre cyclists, bad runners, weak powerlifters, above average at calisthenics
Most runners are not excellent at anything, including running.
And most runners can't sniff crossfit ability in anything but running.
False.
Roger Bannister was a decent rugby player, Peter Snell was a club level tennis player before Arthur Lydiard discovered him. Alan Webb was a successful age group swimmer before moving into running. Grant Fisher was an excellent soccer player in HS. Yeah, there are guys like Gary Martin who are self proclaimd non-athletes but I'd say he's more of an exception than the rule.
I ran at a decent college program and from the 20 guys (Fr. -Sr) on the 800 to xc program I'd say 5 were above average athletes who were varsity level baseball, skiing, and soccer athletes before turning to running full time. 10 of us were pretty normal all around athletes who could hold their own in a pickup basketball game against a random frat squad and 5 couldn't make a layup to save their life. That's just from the distance squad. If you count the sprint and jumps squad our team was full of all-state HS footbal players and had two guys go on to have lengthy careers in the NFL.
I've said repeatedly the key component of crossifit is multiple rep compound movement weight lifting with body to super bodyweight weights. That's a good skill to have but its not truly critical to any major sport. For that reason, its not like you have to be a successful athlete in a major sport to succeed in Crossfit. In fact, things like long arms and legs are actually a disadvantage in most of Olympic lifts Crossfit uses in their workouts.
Some Crossfit Games Finalists come from swimming, rowing, track, and football backgrounds and have decent all around athletic abilities. Some don't.
Again, its not Crossfit training or even the Games that bothers people. It the attitude that (some) Crossfit people have that rubs people the wrong way.
Most runners are not excellent at anything, including running.
And most runners can't sniff crossfit ability in anything but running.
False.
Roger Bannister was a decent rugby player, Peter Snell was a club level tennis player before Arthur Lydiard discovered him. Alan Webb was a successful age group swimmer before moving into running. Grant Fisher was an excellent soccer player in HS. Yeah, there are guys like Gary Martin who are self proclaimd non-athletes but I'd say he's more of an exception than the rule.
I ran at a decent college program and from the 20 guys (Fr. -Sr) on the 800 to xc program I'd say 5 were above average athletes who were varsity level baseball, skiing, and soccer athletes before turning to running full time. 10 of us were pretty normal all around athletes who could hold their own in a pickup basketball game against a random frat squad and 5 couldn't make a layup to save their life. That's just from the distance squad. If you count the sprint and jumps squad our team was full of all-state HS footbal players and had two guys go on to have lengthy careers in the NFL.
I've said repeatedly the key component of crossifit is multiple rep compound movement weight lifting with body to super bodyweight weights. That's a good skill to have but its not truly critical to any major sport. For that reason, its not like you have to be a successful athlete in a major sport to succeed in Crossfit. In fact, things like long arms and legs are actually a disadvantage in most of Olympic lifts Crossfit uses in their workouts.
Some Crossfit Games Finalists come from swimming, rowing, track, and football backgrounds and have decent all around athletic abilities. Some don't.
Again, its not Crossfit training or even the Games that bothers people. It the attitude that (some) Crossfit people have that rubs people the wrong way.
You think "most runners" are represented by Roger Bannister, Peter Snell, and Alan Webb?
Jesus Christ...
They don't claim to be the best at every sport on earth the claim is that they are the "fittest athletes" and if you look at the elites in crossfit they've got a pretty good argument.