Brodey ran 8:00 in high school and you wonder why he's not Top 10 at NCAA X-C. It's a fair point, given that he's at altitude now, on the best team in the country, and this is his third year. Maybe he's not a responder to altitude (or could it hurt him)? Smith talks about Tyler Day being a super responder to altitude.
The rest of your arguments in this thread relate to whether or not he is individualizing the training to fit Brodey and his specific skills compared to the rest of the team. I have no idea, do you?
There's something to be said about a team mindset versus an individual mindset. Has Smith lulled Brodey into thinking he's not as good as the Top 4 so he should be play it safe for team points? I have no idea, do you? That shouldn't be the case in track, so weren't getting ready to find out whether part of your thesis is correct.