XXXX wrote:
Except you are missing the point that Gladwell has a fundamental disagreement with you regarding whether Alberto has done what he is alleged to have done. I do not agree with Gladwell regarding Alberto but that does not necessarily mean Gladwell is being inconsistent. It does mean he is likely incorrect in his assessment of Alberto, however.
Well maybe. I understood Gladwell's statement
"I’m not convinced that all of the bad things said about him are true.”
literally, not that he is challenging the well known facts about Salazar. For example, Gladwell could think that Salazar only used testo on his athletes, not EPO. Or that he only doped Galen, not Kara.
Regarding the facts:
1) Salazar was a drug cheat as athlete.
2) Salazar coached a drug cheat.
3) Salazar is now banned for three doping infractions as coach.
Just going with fact 1 alone, Gladwell should be in favor of Salazar getting DQed in Boston and New York etc. Same goes for fact 2.
Fact 3, well if Gladwell were consistent, Salazar should also lose his wins and titles as coach.