Often wrong but never in doubt wrote:
agip wrote:
she may not be an ideologue but she's promised to take away half the nation's health care
This is false framing. Keep taking your talking points from Republicants and you will play into their hands.
Health insurance is not health care. Nobody's health care would get taken away under a single payer plan. The delivery mechanism would be changed, it would eliminate enormous amounts of bureaucratic costs and would mean that money would go towards health care rather than insurance company profits.
Single payer would cover everybody and save $2 trillion. It is easily the absolutely best, no brainer policy proposal.
fair enough - I'm assuming people understand how this works so I'm using shorthand.
But telling tens of millions of people that they have to abandon the private health insurance they like is indeed taking away their health insurance. A lot of Ds assume that the country is a Warren-esque hellscape of misery and anger, eager for change and newness. It's not. Most people do not want their economic and health care upturned and put at the mercy of bureaucrats. I mean millions of union workers have negotiated for health care...that's gone? Everyone has to throw all their health care insurance into the air and take whatever falls their way?
It might work out in the end, it probably would. But in the meantime you are making an enormous ask of people who are getting good health care.
And you are destroying the jobs of millions of people in the health care industry.
None of this is easy, but the Ds are promising chaos and no one knows how the private insurance industry would get taken out. That's not a great platform plank.