I'd recommend the following criteria...
If you win overall, and I don't care if your state only has gimps and epileptics in track or XC, you get to raise your arms.
if you just got lapped in the 800 then you can still raise your arms, but only AFTER you finish, and then it's just to catch your breath
If you just set a massive PR, and by massive I mean you'd stick your business card in it if it was floating in a toilet, you get to raise your arms
unless you're a gal from Yugoslavia and you haven't shaved your armpits since 3rd grade. Then you can never raise your arms.
If you've just beaten the asswipe that's tormented you all season, then you can raise your arms. Bonus points for squirting perspiration on the asswipe when you do it.
unless the asswipe's mom was just killed by a train while crossing the railroad tracks the in the rain. You don't want to end up in a country and western song son.