Avocados Number wrote:
That may be where we differ. I understand that, in a number of countries, the overriding goal is to get the best talent to the Olympics to represent the country. I don't think that should be the overriding goal in selecting the Olympic team for the United States. To me, for the United States, the process of the selection should be more important than the outcome of the selection. More specifically, I believe that a fair and transparent process is more important than getting the best athletes on the team. That's what I believe the United States should stand for, and that's what I believe track and field competition should be about.
I take your point, and I think it is valid. Without having combed the reams of USATF legalese, I'm sure there was some type of clause buried in there allowing USATF to subvert the arbitrariness of the "rules" for extenuating and extraordinary circumstances. I have no idea.
Nonetheless, I appreciate Kyle King's diplomatic and candid retort. And I agree with a lot of what he writes, including the part about the ethical compromise of running the trials as a workout and impacting others' races. Of course, it works both ways. Should you be running the race at all if you are not near peak form and just going through the motions because you qualified? My biggest issue was with the notion that the #25 runner was somehow "passed over" in the 10,000. That just simply wasn't the case.
Moreover, it's clear that this really gets under people's skin. It almost smells like they really have a discernable vendetta to exercise against Goucher. So, let's see... Adam Goucher and Alan Webb as my two examples? So what kind of precedent has that set? Well, it says that if you are already an Olympian, have run one of the fastest 5ks in the US and faster than almost anyone else in the field within the last TWO years (faster in the case of the 10k), and have been recently competitive in elite, international competition, and can reasonably be expected to compete to make the team, that you MAY be granted an entry without the qualifying time within the arbitrary window. And chances are, whether you actually make the team, you will likely push the pace and be competitive in the field. Yep, makes the Dick Beardsley example a really genuine, compelling analogy, eh?