I largely agree, anony, though I feel it's not a totally black and white issue as few things are, and I have some concerns about tyrannies of majorities and devaluation of healthy competition and so forth. But by and large, yes.
And there's a spectrum, not a sharp divide. I'd think of myself as a runner but closer to jogger than anyone who's ever run as part of a team or club. I'm not awfully fast even for a 39 year old, by nature or training. And though I'll push myself hard as I can in races and pretty hard in workouts, I don't have the natural appetite for pain some of y'all do and have had to cultivate some masochism.
But I will run 80 to 100+ miles a week for a handful of months, 50 to 80 most of the other. I'll carve out the time, I'll make it a top priority and bump plenty of other stuff, I'll run doubles and workouts, in some pretty gruesome hot, cold, and storms. Enjoying most of it but still putting in the miles when it ain't so fun. I won't stop because of a minor ache but I will seriously back off for a few days if a real injury seems at all imminent. I'll run a handful of races and probably a fall marathon, and train and compete my best; but honestly the races might be more important to me as justification for the daily training and the hard work than they are on their own.
I might be shooting for a 1:20 half marathon in fall, and/or a 42k somewhere in the 2:50's, comparable for shorter races. Those times will put me in something like the 97th percentile in big NYC races but I recognize several whole classes of superior runner making up that 2 or 3 percent finishing ahead of me.
I'm mildly amused by both Reebok's "Run Easy" and the PI campaign but have no interest in either of their products.
Most of all, I'll spend way, way too much time on letsrun.
Does that make someone like me a runner or jogger? I can handle "jogger" but would then prefer that you recognize there's different levels of jogger, or a spectrum.
Or at least let's divvy it into three categories: jogger, runner, racer. Someone like me is clearly a runner in this taxonomy.