Pre didn't live long enough to be a member of the 27 club, along with Hendrix, Joplin, James Dean, Robert Johnson, etc. He was 24 when he died. He did everything he did before the age of 25. That inspires people.
One way of thinking about this story is as a status competition among white elites--in this case, elite white running commentators. Abrahamson is trying to prove to his colleagues that he's more woke than the Brojos. Capitalizing "Black" is an important, easy, and ritual first move, in line with most contemporary journalistic style guides. Score one for AA. (Many hard-woke people felt no need to capitalize that word as recently as 24 months ago, but things change.)
On Twitter, AA wrote "The dying-young angle doesn’t explain fully why t/f fetishizes Pre but, say, bkb does not — to anywhere same extent — Len Bias."
https://twitter.com/alanabrahamson/status/1486880655866679297
I'm sure that's true. But I don't see it as a problem. I see it as an interesting question. Why does Tupac get the fetish treatment, and Hendrix, and Pre, but not Len Bias? That's a great question.
The fetish-treatment, the god-who-died-too-young thing, clearly isn't just about having outsized talent and dying young. It's about engaging something much deeper, something mythic.
For Pre, that was several different myths. In the '72 Olympics, it was the Icarus myth: cockiness, arrogance, sees its comeuppance. But that was followed by the prodigal son myth. He learned from the defeat; he humbled himself, went back to ground. He opened himself, in his pain, and gave something back to his community. And then, just as the second big act seemed to be beginning, he was snuffed out--because he was driving too fast. James Dean redux. The James Dean "only the good die young" myth. Whole lotta mythic energy goin on in the Pre world. You can love that or hate that, but it's the truth.
Me, I prefer the people of great talent who nurture and develop their talent, prove themselves over and over, rise to the top and stay at the top. Live long and prosper! Inspire us that way! I prefer Keninisa, Allyson Felix, Usain Bolt, and of course King Haile. They all deserve to have track meets named for them and movies made about their lives. Certainly Tommie Smith and John Carlos deserved the books and movies that have been written and made about what they did. There's some mythic energy there. It's possible to acknowledge that and also recognize that Pre, Nike or not, engages some serious mojo that can and should be appreciated on its own terms.
If Alan Abrahamson had been a little less determined to score points in the Wokest-Among-Us competition with the Brojos, if had actually been making an open minded inquiry, he could have written a much more interesting and long-lasting column.