baa baa wool wrote:
Primo Numero Uno wrote:
Well considering half of the deaths are nursing home those people Covid is generally reducing life expectancy from a few months to not at all. You're assuming everyone else who dies has on average 20 years which is false, most are very sick people. ////
Well yeah if you make up numbers you can arrive at whatever result you want.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.08.20050559v2
As someone who takes this pandemic seriously , I have to tell you that Primo Numero Uno is closer to the mark than you think.
Even the authors of that study admit that the YLL's (years life lost) does not take into account the specific co-morbidities and actual life expectancy of each death but is based on pure age actuarial figures. They promise to fix that as more data comes to hand, in the September study.
In Australia, with good health care, where nursing home admission is a last resort, the stats are as follows:
Covid Deaths
In Aged Care/Nursing homes: 199 out of 266 , 75%
Deaths by age: >80 yr 170 out of 266, 64%
Nursing Home Stats:
Average entry age: 82 yr (M), 84.5 yr (W), with 83% of new residents requiring high level care.
All deaths %: 91% die in nursing home, 9% presumably die back at home/with family
Average life expectancy: (actually length of stay): 2,1 yrs (M), 3.2 yrs (F)
Deaths in first nine months of residence: 40%
You can draw your own conclusions, but almost all the deaths over 80 yo (which itself represents 64% of Covid deaths) are occurring in nursing homes where 40% were going to be gone in 9 months and YLL less than 2.5 yrs, if not closer to 1 yr.
You can expand to include 70-79 yo which comprise a further 66 of the 266 (25 %) which takes the >70 yo total to 236 out of 266 or 89%