wolde wrote:
I have read everything about Tinman, John Kellogg, Canova....all of them have good training ideas but on the otherh hand....they lack some training knowledge, as the importance of recovery between intervals.
I know you love Tinman, Kellogg....because they are from America and Cabral is from Portugal, you know Cabral have incredible knowledge about intervals, repetitions, rest between reps....
Tinman prescribes the same for slow twitch or fast twitch runners, 200m jog recovery between CV-Threshold for all. Is this the right system? I don't thinks so.
Slow twitch runners need longer recovery and probably not jogging, slow walk is better.
Fast twitch should jog between reps, because they lack that aerobic development.
Cabral knows this all better than Tinman, Kellogg....
Have a nice day.
Sorry but there is a lot of things that you got wrong.
Tinmans CV workouts are EASY - they are not a super challenging workout, and not supposed to be. It's short repeats at 10k pace - usually around 1k. This is neither challenging for a ST or a FT runner! Tinman however says that FT runners should run them a bit slower than ST runners, to make them more aerobic and work on their endurance.
Any type of runner should run recovery periods. The question is how fast - according to Tinman, each runner should run so he is recovered for the next rep. In practice this means that ST can often keep shuffling at 7:30-8:00 pace, whereas a FT runner needs to run more like 9:00 pace to recover enough.
Also ST runners could handle alternation workouts very well (like 5x(800 5k pace, 800 steady pace/MP)), whereas FT runners have troubles with that. However, Magness also said that despite this weakness it might still be good for FT runners to do some of these workouts, to work on their weakness.
Apart from that, I fully agree with you - fiber characteristics are extremely important and neglected by 98%+ of trainers. Magness is the only one that really gets it and knows how to individualize (although he is not very successful as coach himself, Houston didn't even make D1 cross country nationals last year if I remember).