I am a senior vice president at an engineering construction firm. I have an employee I suspect has some variety of Autism. He was recently promoted to manage about 8 people. On the surface, he is hard working, friendly, and tries hard-which is how he got promoted. But he is wired differently than anyone I’ve ever known. He thrives on positive feedback-but even mild criticism sends him into a tailspin. Normally, he flits around-seemingly doing his job-but seems to focus on the trivial-and let’s big things slip. He's extremely single minded and focused-but usually not on issues that are critical to our mission. When directed to tighten it up-he loses it-becomes very emotional, and defensive, lashing out at everything and everybody-whether it’s his boss, or his employee. He has lost two great employees-both probably better engineers than he is-because they could not tolerate his behavior. He’s not incompetent—just focuses on things that are tangential to his mission.
The positive feedback tends to create a monster-and he’ll strut around like he’s king of the world. But then the mildest criticism or even question will knock him to the floor—and he becomes even more unbearable. Almost manic-depressive-but the mania is triggered by positive feedback, and the depression by any sort of criticism or questioning. He has been to every management-leadership training known to man--but with all that, he can't relate to people at all. He does not read visual cues or body language at all. He sits on bad news-I guess hoping that it will work out before it becomes trouble.
He’s viewed as manipulative by many-though I wonder if he can help it. Today, I wrote him up for not doing a relatively unimportant cost justification I’d asked for three times. It quickly became about me—and how I did not give him enough time—after he’d told me late last week in no uncertain terms that the justification was not forthcoming. The meeting went from defensive-to a tearful speech about how he loved his job, and no one likes him. I felt terrible-like I’m a bully-but I wonder if he was manipulating me. Dude needs to do his job---and he's not doing it well.
Is this guy Autistic-or bat shit crazy-or both. Is there a role that a guy like this can fulfill? Any thoughts on how to manage someone—and help him manage his crew of 25 year old engineers who are learning to design?