hmmmmmmmmm wrote:
Gibson was a nut, but had an insanely deep guy's team from 2000-2008 or so. Lauren Paquette, local Memphian and 4:09/15:14 performer, spent a year with the Houston girl's team a few years back and nabbed a state championship with seven girls under 19:00 and two under 18:00 in the same season.
Coach Gibson coached 6 boys state championship teams in 12 years from 1997 to 2008 (97, 98, 00, 03, 04, 08) and 3 individual state championships (Doug Ellington ‘93 , Brett Baddorf ‘97, Alex Herringshaw ‘04). ‘97 and ‘04 Houston were some of the most successful Tennessee teams of all time. ‘97 Houston produced 6 all state runners, the most of any school in the AAA division in state history. You may term Gibson a “nut,” but that is a subjective social concern and irrelevant towards evaluating the objective pedigree of these coaches. To be honest, given the lackluster performances over the last decade of most boys Memphis teams I think we could use more “nuts” coaching our runners. I’m sure the guys who won under Gibson will appreciate the memory of being state champions for the rest of their lives. It must be a great feeling.
One coach who is up and coming and flying under the radar some is Bill Gardner. His team at Bartlett finished 2nd in AAA XC this year with a group of almost entirely underclassmen. He has taken a team that had virtually no tradition of excellent XC running and transformed them into a potential state championship winning team. Over the next decade he may establish himself as one of the all time Tennessee coaching greats.
Coach Guy has to be in the conversation of greatest TN XC coaches. He has coached a half dozen sub 9 3200 runners and about as many who have run in the 15:30s and under on the difficult Percy Warner State course. Under his tutelage, Brodey Hasty became one of the best in the nation. His Brentwood team in 2016 scored just 29 points, the lowest ever in TSSAA AAA history. They had 4 runners in the top 6 which is virtually unprecedented. Based solely on the numbers, he is probably the best ever. It is unfortunate that he has been surrounded by controversy in recent years, but again, that is a subjective social concern rather than an objective evaluation of a coach’s abilities. Coach Guy is certainly among the greats.
You mentioned Lauren Paquette. While she is a good person and highly accomplished runner, I don’t think any reasonable person could suggest she deserves to be mentioned among coaching greats. She was not even the head coach for that team. Maybe one day she could be a coaching great, but that day is not today.
Overall, there is a lot of coaching talent in Tennessee and hopefully the tradition of excellent XC running is continued over the next decades.