They should DQ everyone and give the medals to the officials. Everyone is there to see the officials anyway.
They should DQ everyone and give the medals to the officials. Everyone is there to see the officials anyway.
Opinions don't matter; only the rules book wrote:
Crybabies wrote:
No she should not be DQ'd and this should NEVER be a DQ! Change the rule to where it only applies if someone forcefully pushes someone to the outside to avoid being passed.
This post summarizes EXACTLY the problem people on this thread have. IT DOESN'T MATTER IF IT SHOULD BE A DQ; IT ONLY MATTERS WHAT THE RULES BOOK SAYS. And according to the rules book this is a clear DQ. It falls under IAAF Rule 163: Obstruction. We have to "change the rule" in order to make it fit YOUR definition of a DQ.
It is like the arguments regarding what is a catch and what is not a catch in the NFL this past season. You can agree or disagree with the rules but they are still the rules. The runner here clearly moved from lane 1 into at least the outside of late 2 in order to prevent the oncoming third place runner from passing. Lanes are four feet wide so this is a significant distance to move right. Contact is NOT a requirement; only impeding the progress of the other runner matters. She was not moving right to avoid a lapped runner as this person was at least 10 meters in front of here with only maybe 30 meters to go. She has a free straight line to the finish line so there is no reason to divert her direction.
Actually it doesn't even matter whether she did it "IN ORDER TO PREVENT...". All that matters is she did it and impeded; intent is not relevant.
The rules-based answer is obvious; the bantering all about what people wish were the rules.
observer_of_things wrote:
rojo wrote:
Al Sal got GG DQd. Is it time one of his athletes gets DQd?
I personally don't think a DQ is the right penalty. I think there should be a penalty where you put Muir 2nd and Hassan 3rd but I'm sorry - you can't do what Hassan just did.
Whuh?
How on earth would this be a DQ? Hassan was ahead of Muir and was clear to move right in to unoccupied space. Muir could still have passed further to the right if she was actually fast enough. This is all totally normal racing.
Only the most cowardly of SJW types would answer like this. Hassan should be thrown out. If it were the other way around the same coward would be clamoring for the hateful oppressive white woman to be banned for life.
The elbow, and the drift are Standard Operating Procedure for Hassan. In the 2017 world's, Jenny used that against her by passing on the inside in the final straight.
ex-runner wrote:
LetsRun.com wrote:
We don't want a DQ but thinks the rules should be changed so she could be placed 4th.
http://www.letsrun.com/news/2018/03/sifan-hassan-dqd-impeding-laura-muir/Nonsense.
Actually total nonsense.
+1
Stop it already.
No dq. Just racing
Only Rojo the clueless would be worrying about an athlete who WASN'T DQd in a meet with 30 other DQs.
This thread seems like a premonition for the ridiculous amount of actual DQs that were yet to come lol.
Such a nice woman.
It’s frustrating to see such dirty tactics, if she is not fast enough at the end, she should just accept the fact. Anyway, this will cause more people to dislike her, cheater.
I’m a D2 female runner. Our coach explicitly told us not to visit LetsRun forums.
Great interview with Steve Cram - says Jakob has no chance of WRs this year
RENATO can you talk about the preparation of Emile Cairess 2:06
adizero Road to Records with Yomif Kejelcha, Agnes Ngetich, Hobbs Kessler & many more is Saturday
2024 College Track & Field Open Coaching Positions Discussion
Hats off to my dad. He just ran a 1:42 Half Marathon and turns 75 in 2 months!