my knee grows wrote:
I know this is a stupid question, but does "natural born citizen" have to mean someone is born on US soil? Can someone born to US parents who happen to be in Canada really not be the POTUS? Born to US citizen parents, US citizen for entire lifetime. Seems to be a "natural born citizen" to me. Is that not the case?
If that is the case, then it really does not matter where Obama was actually born. Does it? His mother was always a US citizen her entire life, an by birthright Barack Obama has been a citizen his entire life. Doesn't that make him a "natural born citizen?"
This issue has been hashed over hundreds of times. No, you do *not* have to be born on US soil to be a natural born citizen (although it is sufficient). However, it is not enough to have a US citizen as a parent. There are rules about the age of the parent and the number of years they have spent in the US, etc, etc. If Obama *had* been born in Kenya then he would not be a natural born citizen because of these rules. However, he was not born in Kenya, so it's a non-issue.
It is a little known fact that one of the candidates for President in 2008 was not born on US soil and has refused to make his birth certificate public.
That candidate was John McCain.