danno wrote:
He would be taking out an unsecured personal loan on that $5000. All thing being equal, and given the tighter credit now than in '05, the rate on that loan will probably be significantly higher than the open loan on the SUV he has right now. That is not going away in 13 months of 380 pmts, also he could be $6K flipped in the SUV which makes it even worse. I agreee w/ your sentiments on debt, but sometimes the "stupid tax" can be paid by installments. I think he is better off riding out the existing loan.
So, if the rate on a personal loan is a little higher, then pay $400 a month toward it and get it gone in 13 months anyway. MUCH better than having to pay for that vehicle for a few more years -- more on gas, more on payments, more in insurance than a smaller used car.
Rule of thumb should be that when you add up everything you own with a motor, it shouldn't be more than half your annual income (and ideally those things should be bought with cash -- no payments). Depending on how long he's been a teacher, he may or may not be ok with that rule of thumb. In any event, it seems he's making some correct decisions now -- going to get a summer job to help pay debt down, thinking of getting rid of this car (which he should as soon as possible).