The bottom line is: chasing PRs is not a good feeling. Cavemen did not run hard because they saw some clock about to climb over 15 minutes and neither do we. Cavemen ran hard to catch food, compete with each other for scarce resources, impress the opposite sex, etc.
It's about competition. And what the USATF has just done is eliminated competition for a specific demograph of runners: guys who are post-collegiate, and national class. Not international class, but not regional class either.
If you are international class, you go to the Olympic trials because you have at least a slim chance of making the team. And if you make it then you have a slim chance of getting a medal. And if you don't make the Olympics then you go to a world marathon major and try and mix it up the best you can.
If you are regional class, you just go for big regional races. For instance, if you're a 2:30 marathoner, placing top 10 at the Philly marathon would be pretty sweet.
But what if you're national class? ie, you're not one of the top 10 in the country. But you might be top 50. And you want to prove that you are 50th, and not 150th. Where do you go? That caliber of runner will not get excited about being 4th versus 6th at Philly.
In college they fix this problem with a thing called NCAA xc championships. Yes, that race is about McDougal and Rupp. But it is also about the guy that passes 50 people during the race and gets that last All-American spot, when everyone thought he wouldn't crack the top 100.
We used to have a version of this, for people who were just as competitive as that college kid, but older with more slow-twitch fibers. It was called the Olympic Trials. But no more. Thanks USATF.
At least the international guys still have something to run for, as do the regional guys.
What if they made the Olympic standard 2:10? It's about medals right? No point in admitting a 2:11 guy who will be happy to get top 10, and will not see 3rd place.
To that 2:11 guy, 10th place is everything. And to the 2:21 guy, 50th at the OT is everything. Just like to the 17:30 5k runner, the local turkey trot is everything.
We might be able to fix this problem. We've gotta find some other race that counts as a national championship. But that's not easy when there's like 8 billion USATF road championships. Placing top 50 at any one of those hardly makes you one of the best 50 runners in the country. And we all know it.