No, no, no, no. We do this every year. If Edinboro has their best day they can be 4th, Haven can be 5th. Last year Edinboro and Mansfield were both getting top 6. It's nonsense.
Let's look at the 5th ranked team on each side.
Men - Augie
Karbo - 19th @ cross nats last year, 8:50 steeple PR, 3:50 1500m
Braun - 24th @ XC nats in 2012, 58th last year, 9:08 steeple PR
Hauge - 64th @ XC nats in 2012, 14:36 5k PR
Carda - no notable XC experience - 14:52 5k PR, 30:53 10k PR
Ellingson - no notable XC experience - 14:51 5k, 31:08 10k
Gleason - 59th @ XC nats in 2013, 14:43 5k PR,
Klecker - 79th @ XC nats in 2013, 8:23 3k, 14:47 5k
I'll spare you posting the comparable Haven runners. It's not a pretty comparison. You have to assume all 7 Haven runners made a giant leap forward from last spring just to compete with the Augie team.
Women - Hillsdale
Oren - 91st @ XC nats 2013, 4:51 mile, 10:27 steeple
Galat - 63rd @ XC nats in 2013, 4:55 mile, 16:53 5k
McIntyre - 2:19/5:08 High School PRs, beat Edinboro's #2 @ Louisville
Oren - 108 @ XC nats in 2013, 17:53 5k PR, beat Edinboro's #3 @ Louisville
Kilgore - 133 @ XC nats in 2013, 18:08 5k , did not race at Louisville
Royer - No XC experience of note, 5:02 miler, beat Edinboro's #4 @ Louisville.
Kerst - 2:11 800m, 5:01 mile, finished just behind Edinboro's 5 @ Louisville (when she was the team's #8).
Edinboro's women compare well to Hillsdale, the gap between PRs isn't significant at every position. However, at Louisville Hillsdale won at every position 1-7. Plus, Hillsdale has added in another top 5 runner.
The bottom line is, the PSAC, since the end of 2004 has a ceiling of 7th/8th at the NCAA meet. The only teams to break through that ceiling in the last decade were led by Neely Spence and Mary Dell. The 4th place team had 3 girls who concluded their careers with top 3 finishes at the NCAA meet. That's the type of talent and achievement it takes to crack the top 5 at DII nationals. The Edinboro women and Lock Haven men are very good, but they aren't top 5 good.