After reading the LetsRun article in which they named Kiptum their Athlete of the Year, here are a couple more reasons Crouser is more deserving.
#9: Crouser was MUCH more dominant.
LetsRun asked us to appreciate Kiptum's dominance. I do. Winning London by 2:58 and Chicago by 3:27 is amazing. Winning any world marathon major by such a large margin is amazing. But it's not unheard of. In fact, just last year Kipchoge won Berlin by nearly 6 minutes!
More importantly, Kiptum's dominance pales in comparison to Crouser's. Kiptum's London time was 2.4% faster than the runner-up, and his Chicago time was 2.8% faster than the runner-up. On average, he was 2.6% better than the second-fastest guy. Now let's look at Crouser's victory at the world championships. Crouser's championship record throw was 23.51. Second place was way back in 22.34. That's a difference of 1.17m. Crouser was 5.2% better!! His percentage was twice as good as Kiptum's!
To help you understand how astounding being 5.2% better than the runner-up is, consider that Bolt's 19.19 WR was only 3.1% better than second-place in that race, and Kipyegon's 3:49 1500 WR when she won by almost 8 seconds was only 3.4% better than second-place!
Now, you might be wondering: is it common for a shot putter to win by over a meter like Crouser did in Budapest? The answer is NO. Since the world championships started in 1983, no shot putter has won a championship competition by over a meter. The largest margin of victory before Crouser's was 0.92m in 1991, over 30 years ago. The average margin of victory in the shot put for all world championship and Olympic competitions from 1983 to 2022 was 0.34m, and the median was 0.29m. Crouser won by 1.17! Absolutely unprecedented in the professional era. You'd have to go way back over a century ago to the 1900 Olympics to find another man who won a global shot put championship by over a meter.
If dominance is going to be the main deciding factor for crowning Athlete of the Year, then Crouser is the deserving winner, and it's not even close.