We have merged two threads on this topic into 1 and kept the title of the longer thread. The other thread was called, "Adeline Johnson, high school senior, misses state due to biological male taking the last spot in California."
You have the terminology wrong. We are talking one class of women versus another. Fix that and then we can talk.
When an adult human has XX chromosomes they are a woman, regardless of what they want to call themselves. When an adult human has XY chromosomes they are a man, regardless of what they want to call themselves.
Demonstrably false!
46,XX testicular difference of sex development is a condition in which individuals with two X chromosomes in each cell, the pattern typically found in females, have a male appearance. People with this condition have male external genitalia.
Your disregard for biological females is hateful. Telling biological females too bad deal with it has nothing to do with sports. It's denying all of their identities.
Based on the thousands of biological female identities that you are disregarding, you appear to be more hateful than most.
When an adult human has XX chromosomes they are a woman, regardless of what they want to call themselves. When an adult human has XY chromosomes they are a man, regardless of what they want to call themselves.
Demonstrably false!
46,XX testicular difference of sex development is a condition in which individuals with two X chromosomes in each cell, the pattern typically found in females, have a male appearance. People with this condition have male external genitalia.
Your entire argument is easily defeated in 10 seconds.
You are supplying advanced graduate level concepts to those whose simpthink doesn’t allow for more nuance beyond “just because I’m a chair doesn’t make me a chair” or “boys are boys and girls are girls, period”.
When an adult human has XX chromosomes they are a woman, regardless of what they want to call themselves. When an adult human has XY chromosomes they are a man, regardless of what they want to call themselves.
Teaching Differences of Sex DevelopmentIn this video, Jennifer Potter, M.D. and Katharine Baratz Dalke, M.D. discuss how to effectively teach differences of ...
I’m saying it’s hateful to look at a person who was born a girl and chooses to transition to live life as a man and say, “biologically, you’ll never be a man.” The only goal of that statement is to make that person feel inferior, to disregard a deeply personal part of their being. When you say things with the expressed purpose of breaking someone down, it is the definition of hate.
Again, I’m not talking about sports here. This is in direct response to people who say “these athletes I’ll never be women/men.” That goes beyond sports. It’s a mean thing that comes from a place of hate that honestly has nothing to do with the person saying it.
I’m saying it’s hateful to look at a person who was born a girl and chooses to transition to live life as a man and say, “biologically, you’ll never be a man.” The only goal of that statement is to make that person feel inferior, to disregard a deeply personal part of their being. When you say things with the expressed purpose of breaking someone down, it is the definition of hate.
Again, I’m not talking about sports here. This is in direct response to people who say “these athletes I’ll never be women/men.” That goes beyond sports. It’s a mean thing that comes from a place of hate that honestly has nothing to do with the person saying it.
Well considering the person that you are labeling as hateful is talking about sports, what's your point?
You've move the goalposts away from the conversation in order to engage in name calling.
I’m saying it’s hateful to look at a person who was born a girl and chooses to transition to live life as a man and say, “biologically, you’ll never be a man.” The only goal of that statement is to make that person feel inferior, to disregard a deeply personal part of their being. When you say things with the expressed purpose of breaking someone down, it is the definition of hate.
Again, I’m not talking about sports here. This is in direct response to people who say “these athletes I’ll never be women/men.” That goes beyond sports. It’s a mean thing that comes from a place of hate that honestly has nothing to do with the person saying it.
I agree but it’s gotten to a point where they just want us to ignore basic truths to accommodate their feelings and that’s not fair.
and the truth is trans women are NOT cis women. Can we at least agree there?