2600 bro wrote:
0.26% doesn't really tell the whole story. COVID is more than significantly worse compared to other seasonal respiratory viruses.
https://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1336841338923278336?s=20
You try looking into those numbers? First, the ranges are huge (6 or more levels of magnitude difference). Second, cross reference some of the assumed values against documented values. For the 0-24 age group, it is estimating we should have on the order of 42% excess deaths at a 100% infection rate(If you cross against SS administration actuarial death tables). Conservatively estimating a 30% infection rate at this point, we should have 12% excess deaths in that age group. The reality is we have 0 excess deaths in that age group. So either we are at a 0% infection rate, or the numbers in your graph that you are holding out as evidence are completely fabricated.
Lets go on to the 25-44 year old age group. Your chart says that at a 100% rate of infection, we would expect about 50% excess deaths. The CDC tells us we have about 7% excess deaths in that age group (most of which can be attributed to deaths of despair at this point, but I digress), which would indicate by your charts that we are at an infection point of 14%, which is closer to a CFR than an IFR value at this point (unless you believe that all actual cases have been logged and that there are no asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic cases that were not accounted for). By the way, the IFR you are holding to in your charts for this age group (average of 0.09% ) is about 7 times greater than the CFR for the US Military at this point (15 deaths out of 120,106 cases).
Continuing this exercise, here is what the current excess deaths would indicate when crossed against SS death tables.
Age Group Excess deaths at 100% inf. Actual Excess deaths Indicated Infection Rate
45-64 77.44% 9.52% 12.3%
65-74 94.49% 20% 21.1%
75-84 89.54% 23.08% 25.8%
85+ 80.60% 11.11% 13.8%
When you get into those upper age groups, it is disingenuous to attribute all of those deaths to COVID at it neglects to acknowledge all of the other conditions an individual has acquired over their life. Using the Social Security actuarial death tables, the chance of a person over 90 dying in a given year is 19.98% even without COVID, the chance of a person between 80-89 dying in a given year is 10.33%.