If you let them sit in your closet for more than six months they will be old and outdated.
There will be a newer, better and faster 5%, a 5% Beyond, etc.models being released, especially in an Olympic year.
Even the shoe laces will be better.
Wear those old shoes and you will be smoked by lesser runners wearing the latest/greatest technology.
You really need to plan your training, peaks and race schedule to coincide with the new model releases to do well (unless you are sponsored).
The top pros gain an edge by wearing very new shoes that still retain extra energy
(at the molecular level) from the recently completed manufacturing process.
When shoes start to loose that nice new shoe synthetic smell, they start to lose their pop. Shoes with a stronger smell are fresher and faster.
You may not actually run faster in the newest shoes, but your perceived effort level, heartrate, and efficiency will all be better. And you will recover faster. You can best prove this for yourself by racing an all out marathon wearing a different shoe on each foot.
Top shoe marketing gurus, people with better prs than me, and runners that looked relaxed told me all this, so its truth.