100m wrote:
The issue here is not that assuming Dibaba uses hot sauce is wrong, but that assuming Muir is innocent and clean is naïve...Let's apply standards equally and rationally.
Thank you. This is very well put.
I think naïve is exactly right. Muir ran the 16th fastest 1500 ever. The only woman who's run faster in the last twenty years is Dibaba. It's easy to believe that everyone else who ran faster than Muir was cheating; eight of those times came in two races in China, and the rest belong to eastern Europeans running at the height of the EPO era. Many of the women slower than Muir are also suspicious.
And yet somehow people are sure that she, and she alone, is clean.
At the height of MaryMania, I asked an elite runner if he thought Cain was clean. I think his answer applies here: "I certainly hope so."