robert678 wrote:
She's a kid. Let her enjoy HS and College running. Mary Cain went pro in HS when she didn't have competition, and she only got worse each year. Alexa Efraimson did the same thing, and while she hasn't improved from HS she's still competent.
Serious, driven athletes, regardless of how old they are, don't want to "enjoy HS and college running," especially if it means time trialing minutes ahead of everyone else who is nominally in the same race. They want to compete at the highest level that their talent and training permit. In a lot of sports, teenagers are routinely world class, and nobody suggests that they should just focus on NCAA competition until they're in the mid-20s. It seems to be mostly in running, and mostly with young women, that everyone is suddenly concerned that their fragile psyches won't be able to handle competing at the level that their talent can take them to.
As for the keyboard diagnoses of various runners whom you don't know, there's there's nothing to indicate that going pro too early ruined either Cain of Efraimson. Cain's issue is obvious, and I would rather not discuss it. I doubt that being in the NCAA would've helped. Efraimson was elite when she went pro and has in fact improved. Maybe not as much as some hoped, but female mid-d prodigies rarely drop huge time during their early adult years. Sometimes they have to move up in distance (or way up, in the case of Jordan), and sometimes they just have to ride out the few years of stagnation that seem to result from the latter stages of female puberty.