Biggest Loser Controversy: Contestant Supposedly Lost too much weight?!

Nothing against Hasay, but if you watched the workout on Flotrack she and Cain did after the mile…She is clearly VERY skinny. If I didn't know her and someone told me she was 16, I would have believed them right away. So would anyone else. I understand that she needs to be skinny to run fast at long distance, and I have no problem with it, but if you've seen her recently you know thats not a good look. I'm sure the NOP has control, but its borderline and I doubt few would want a GF that skinny.[/quote]

________________________________________

I completely agree with this assessment of Jordan Hasay's appearance, especially when compared to her college days. However, she has transitioned from mid-d runner to long-d runner. If she's healthy, meaning that she's eating right and has no nutritional deficiencies, it's probably good for speed.

HOWEVER, Galen Rupp does not look any better, and people rarely critique his body in this kind of detail. It's sort of understood that he's doing whatever he needs to do in order to be the best. Sure, you have the x-fit whack jobs denigrating his masculinity, but most people can understand that a male athlete is using his body to achieve excellence in a sport, with all of the attendant risks that that entails. People are far less likely to accept that a woman may be doing the same thing.

I'm not going to go around trashing Galen Rupp and his athletic pursuits just because he doesn't fit the ideal standard for men I want to sleep with.

Skooled wrote:

Are they on the "ranch" for 4.5 months then go home for 3 months where nobody sees them?

you don't know how much they lost on their own outside of the ranch vs what they last weighed on the ranch.

Also keep in mind that one show doesn't necessarily cover 1 week. I heard that they typically use a 10 day timeframe for their weekly summery. Not much cheating there but it helps...

FWIW, I don't have a fatty fetish. My girlfriend is 5'4" and only 155 lbs. She has nice curves.

Xfit_guy_the_reaI_1 wrote:

FWIW, I don't have a fatty fetish. My girlfriend is 5'4" and only 155 lbs. She has nice curves.

That says it all.

Maybe it's an entirely different woman and the original overweight one is being hidden away somewhere.

Also, i am not attracted to women.

Xfit_guy_the_real_1 wrote:

Yuck, she looks like a female runner now. No curves to be seen anywhere. Lost too much weight to fast and didn't do the right strength training (squats, deadlift, lunges is all a woman should do). Here shape is to "square".

She should have probably stopped halfway through her journey.

Xfit_guy_the_reaI_1 wrote:

FWIW, I don't have a fatty fetish. My girlfriend is 5'4" and only 155 lbs. She has nice curves.

Um, hate to tell you this but your girlfriend is a fat chick.

Yea, like I said, I understand that she needs to be that skinny, but I don't believe anyone that say they prefer that look over when shes a bit more 'normal'. Difference with her and Galen Rupp is that skinny boys aren't losing any 'curves', wont be the same difference (altough long distance women rarely have much curves).

Last part of your comment, completely agree.

Yea, like I said, I understand that she needs to be that skinny, but I don't believe anyone that say they prefer that look over when shes a bit more 'normal'. Difference with her and Galen Rupp is that skinny boys aren't losing any 'curves', wont be the same difference (altough long distance women rarely have much curves).

Last part of your comment, completely agree.

Barakus Obama wrote:

Difference with her and Galen Rupp is that skinny boys aren't losing any 'curves'

Nope but they are losing MUSCLE. And look totally unattractive to any REAL woman. So what's the point?

This is another picture of her. Doesn't look healthy to me

http://www.eonline.com/eol_images/Entire_Site/201415/rs_560x415-140205082155-1024.Rachel-Frederickson-Super-Slim-Biggest-Looser.jl.020614_copy.jpg

her mouth is huge - probably why she got fat!