Layden on Lagat

The might of the benjamins.

Sure, I agree. However, it's history at this point and there's nothing any of us can really do about it outside of what any of us has already done. I have a bigger problem with his EPO positive, but I can't do anything about that, either.

I'm a big Tim Layden fan but read 2 paragraphs and had to comment:

The 48-flat relay split that Allyson Felix threw down Sunday night in the women's 4X400-relay? It was the singular moment of the championships.

How can he say such a thing. i have trouble calling something 98% of people who watched the meet know nothing about the singular moment of the games.

So lagat would struggle to make the Kenyan team? Really?

I guess I missed his two gold medals. When you win a gold medal at a world championship doesn't it usually mean you are better than everyone else in the WORLD?

Did you notice how lagat was kind of struggling and not his usual self early in the season? There's a distinct possibility that could have cost him at the kenyan trials. Hey, props for peaking at the right time, but he may nto of had that luxury as a kenyan.

wejo wrote:

I'm a big Tim Layden fan but read 2 paragraphs and had to comment:

The 48-flat relay split that Allyson Felix threw down Sunday night in the women's 4X400-relay? It was the singular moment of the championships.

How can he say such a thing. i have trouble calling something 98% of people who watched the meet know nothing about the singular moment of the games.

Weldon, I didn't see the race, but a friend of mine (quite the track fan) had exactly the same opinion of her race. Remember, there are events shorter than 800m that matter.

PDubbs wrote:

Did you notice how lagat was kind of struggling and not his usual self early in the season? There's a distinct possibility that could have cost him at the kenyan trials. Hey, props for peaking at the right time, but he may nto of had that luxury as a kenyan.

You've got your years mixed up. Lagat got citizenship in 2004, which has nothing to do with his performances this year.

Alright i could be wrong here but i am assuming that the kenyan team for the world champs were picked based on kenyan trials earlier this summer. Hence Lagat not being in top form earlier this summer could have cost him a spot to compete in the world champs

hardset nipples wrote:

Sure, I agree. However, it's history at this point and there's nothing any of us can really do about it outside of what any of us has already done. I have a bigger problem with his EPO positive, but I can't do anything about that, either.

What can you have a problem with? He's never tested positive.

Incorrect, sir.

PDubbs wrote:

Alright i could be wrong here but i am assuming that the kenyan team for the world champs were picked based on kenyan trials earlier this summer. Hence Lagat not being in top form earlier this summer could have cost him a spot to compete in the world champs

The point is, that is irrelevant.

How is it irrelevant? I was responding to this,

"So lagat would struggle to make the Kenyan team? Really?

I guess I missed his two gold medals. When you win a gold medal at a world championship doesn't it usually mean you are better than everyone else in the WORLD?"

Hence, since Lagat was not running as well early in the season he may not have made the kenyan team due to all their depth. So yes despite his two golds he may not of had the opportunity to be in the WC if he was still kenyan. This isn't that complicated.

hey didnt he test positive for EPO?

Malmo, R.L. Scribner-

I believe that PDubbs was trying to suggest that, were Lagat still a Kenyan citizen, because of the slow start (or rough start) to his summer, he would have struggled to make the Kenyan WCs team. From a strategic standpoint, it makes Lagat's decision to apply for US citizenship appear quite wise.

It seems that PDubbs was speaking in hypothetically. So, it's not wholly relevant, but it's certainly not irrelevant, and he didn't get his timing wrong.

Peter

B was negative

"Speaking hypothetically"

Lorenzo the Magnificent wrote:

a) He became a U.S. citizen in March 2004, before the Olympic Games, and yet he didn't announce it until after he had competed for Kenya in Athens, having never told the Kenyan federation. Lagat says he got surprised when his application for citizenship moved more quickly than he expected. That's plausible. And ONCE HE BECAME A U.S. CITIZEN, HE WAS INELIGIBLE TO RUN THE '04 GAMES FOR EITHER COUNTRY. And he knew it. "I knew the only way for me to run was to just run for Kenya," Lagat told a small group of journalists in Osaka. It was a tough situation, and Lagat dealt with it by deceiving everyone involved.

This is an inaccurate conclusion. There are many athletes who hold dual citizenship. Having such status does not disqualify the athlete from competing in the Olympics. There is a 3-year waiting period once an athlete has achieved citizenship before he/she can represent that country in international competitions. That is why Lagat could not represent the U.S. (although he had citizenship status) until the 2007 World Championships. He could have represented the U.S. had his previous country granted him permission, but Kenya did not, probably because they wanted him to represent them in the Olympics. Therefore, if Lagat wanted to compete in the 2004 Olympics, the only country he could have represented at the time was Kenya. There was no deception on Lagat's part. Just because the U.S. does not recognize dual citizenships does not mean other countries do not. Lagat could go back and represent Kenya (they'd love to have him), he just chooses not to.

Almost every one of your sentences are factually incorrect. The most important facts in this matter are 1) The US DOES recognize dual citizenships, 2) Kenya DOES NOT, and finally 3) Lagat chose to keep his citizenship a secret.

Peter wrote:

Malmo, R.L. Scribner-

I believe that PDubbs was trying to suggest that, were Lagat still a Kenyan citizen, because of the slow start (or rough start) to his summer, he would have struggled to make the Kenyan WCs team. From a strategic standpoint, it makes Lagat's decision to apply for US citizenship appear quite wise.

It seems that PDubbs was speaking in hypothetically. So, it's not wholly relevant, but it's certainly not irrelevant, and he didn't get his timing wrong.

If Lagat was still a Kenyan, do you think he'd have had a slow start this Summer? Smoke that in your hypothetical pipe.