I am happy to explain the resentment for Tracksmith! It's my bread and butter, especially every time they come up with a ridiculous new product or collection. I'll try to keep things concise.
I'll preface this by saying that I really do like some of their programs for amateur athlete support, as well as what Russell Dinkins does to try and save college programs and grow youth running programs. However their brand and the products they sell really rub me the wrong way. It's so ironic that they play up the celebration of amateurs and blue-collar runners, when their products are anything but blue-collar, in fact they're very inaccessible for average people. Running has always been the sport for the masses, where there are relatively less barriers to entry than other sports, but Tracksmith could not let this happen. The whole brand reeks of northeast/Ivy League elitism (which I have grown up around and have a strong distaste for, so I know it when I see it) and their target customers are the wealthiest people in the suburbs and the city. They made a lot of noise about honoring Bill Rodgers, even though realistically, someone like him in his competitive years would have thought a 100% cotton t-shirt for over $60 was the douchiest thing ever. Boston Bill was a true blue-collar runner who rummaged through a trash can for his gear. Tracksmith is also a parody of itself: their mascot is the hare from the tortoise and the hare... the hare LOSES the race because it gets too distracted by a bunch of other stupid external crap (Tracksmith).
When Tracksmith launched their "No Days Off" winter apparel collection last year, it was comical how expensive everything was. If I need a full kit from Tracksmith to brave the elements in New England, I could just buy TWO treadmills for the same cost and never need to worry about the weather. Or I could buy a round trip flight to somewhere down south for the winter for a similar price. Also "No Days Off" possibly glorifying burnout?! ...that can be a separate conversation.
The "Eliot Runner" is no better. Vintage Tracksmith move to not even show full pictures of it and say that we need to be at London or Chicago or at their Boston Frathouse in order to check it out. "Reserve your spot in line today". Gatekeeping at its finest. $200 for a pebax shoe with no plate? I can get the Nike Zoomx Invincible or a Saucony Freedom for much less, and both will have much better details in the upper, etc. Look at how thick those laces are! No information on heel-toe drop, weight, or literally anything, other than pebax followed by some relatable imagery about the feeling of packed dirt in Anywhere, New England. And I agree with another poster's point that this description creates confusion about whether it's supposed to be some sort of hybrid trail shoe.
Sure, Tracksmith is a great conversation starter. If I see someone rocking the hare I can instantly ask them if they went to Yale or Harvard, if they prefer missionary or missionary, or whether they plan to have a kid when they're 50 years old in Lexington, Concord, or Weston? People who were excited to buy the Allbirds "Dasher" will buy this shoe. It's gonna be a no for me.