No argument that it makes great TV. In fact marathons should pay runners to run aggressive like this instead of paying pacers to run even. It makes it more fun to watch. Maybe give out a most aggressive money award or something.
The thing is, you can’t run like that when you are out classed and expect a good result. If you are the 15th best xc runner in the ncaa, surging off the front continually is not a good race strategy. You aren’t “hurting” anyone but yourself.
It is not really a defensible opinion that CJ wouldn’t run faster in this race with a more even paced race. If you combine that with some of his sub optimal training like running 2:10 in practice he has the potential to be much faster that his results indicate.
You can read this as tearing him down, but it is instead wanting him to succeed.