HOKA ONE ONE Mach 5

Overall Grades And Reviews

8.8 Overall Grade
60 reviews

A popular HOKA shoe that gets great marks in fit, comfort, cushioning, and appearance with lower marks in durability.

How This Shoe Compares To Its Competitors

Price Information

Buy This Shoe

Select men or women above.
$140 $97
Flame/Dandelion

Pros

  • A majority of reviewers like this shoe more than their last shoe.
  • Reviewers rate this shoe better than the HOKA ONE ONE Mach 4.
  • One of the most popular shoes among LetsRun.com readers.
  • Rated among the top 10% of shoes overall.
  • Rated among the top 5% of shoes on comfort.
  • Rated among the top 25% of shoes on cushioning.

Cons

  • A couple of reviewers wished it had a rubber outsole for grip and durability.
  • Rated among the bottom 10% of shoes on durability.

LetsRun.com Reviewer Ratings

Shoe Comparison

Shoe comparison
HOKA ONE ONE Mach 5
HOKA ONE ONE Mach 6
Brooks Ghost 15
HOKA ONE ONE Bondi 8
Image
HOKA ONE ONE Mach 5
This Shoe
HOKA ONE ONE Mach 6
Newer Version
Brooks Ghost 15
Top Rated Trainer For Sale
HOKA ONE ONE Bondi 8
Most Comfortable Trainer For Sale
Shoe Properties
Shoe Type
Trainer
Trainer
Trainer
Trainer
Pronation Control
Neutral
Neutral
Neutral
Weight
8 oz. (men's), 7 oz. (women's)
7.4 oz. (men's), 6.7 oz. (women's)
9.6 oz. (men's), 8.4 oz. (women's)
11.1 oz. (men's), 10.1 oz. (women's)
Stack Height
30mm.
37mm.
35mm.
43mm.
Forefoot Height
25mm.
32mm.
23mm.
39mm.
Drop Height
5 mm.
5 mm.
12 mm.
4 mm.
Upper material
Jacquard Mesh, Anatomical Achilles
Refined 3D Fit Print mesh, Recycled Materials include:
Engineered mesh, Lycra comfort frame, Internal heel counter, Pillowed Tongue
Shoe Released
Q2 2022
Q1 2024
Q4 2022
Q3 2022
MSRP
$140
$140
$165
LRC Ratings
Out of 10
Overall
8.8
9.2
9.0
Comfort
9.1
9.1
9.7
Cushioning
8.8
9.1
9.6
Durability
6.9
8.8
8.1
Appearance
8.7
8.2
7.8
Value
8.5
8.5
7.7

Reader Reviews

  • LRC Editor's Choice

    Favourite Shoe to Date

    50 miles per week, underpronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    8.0
    Durability
    9.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    8.0

    This shoe is incredibly versatile, I use it for many different aspects of training. From long runs, to tempo runs, grass thresholds and track work, it is a reliable shoe that always shows up. I ran about 1000km on my last pair and didn't notice a dramatic decrease in performance until about 850km. I wouldn't recommend using them for that long, however they still performed great for me and I only replaced them once all the bounciness was gone. It took a about a week of running in them for me to feel accustomed with the how they felt on my feet. Overall they are the best none-plated shoe I have worn and I regularly work out in them when I don't want to wear a plated shoe.

  • LRC Editor's Choice

    My Everyday Go-To Shoe

    30 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    6.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    7.0

    The Mach 5 is an excellent shoe.  It's incredibly light without sacrificing cushion.  The cushion is nice and soft (even though the shoe is considered on the firmer side for Hoka), but still manages to feel very springy and responsive.  It's like a perfect middle ground between regular cushion and max cushion *chef's kiss*.  The fit is solid, roomy toe-box but still secure in the midfoot and heel.  I  find they run a little big so I half size down from my normal running shoe size.  The rocker still does it's job even though the shoe isn't nearly as stiff as some of it's Hoka relatives. I find the transition through my stride to feel smooth and natural.  The durability could be better, however.  Since there is no blown rubber on the bottom (one of the reasons the shoe is so light), the foam outsole wears down quickly.  In my experience, they start to look worn within 50 miles and by about 400-450 miles I retire them because rocks and sticks tend to poke through.  I have also noticed consistent wear in the fabric around my ankle bone and where my insoles sit, though it's never bothered me. My only other (petty) complaint is the thin, flat laces that tend to be long and twist. 

  • LRC Editor's Choice

    Hoka Mach 5: Best do-it-all trainer

    50 miles per week, neutral pronator, high arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    9.0
    Cushioning
    9.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    9.0
    Value
    7.0

    I am on my 4th pair of Mach 5’s, after running in the Mach 4’s previously. The Mach 5 is a perfect utility shoe for me. I use it for all of my training runs, slow, short, long, fast - no matter the distance or tempo, the Mach 5 exceeds. The upper fits like a glove, and it feels very light on foot, with a rockered geometry that guides you effortlessly to put one foot in front of the other. While some complain about the outsole durability, I have personally not had this problem, with my shoes lasting ~500 miles/pair on average. I couldn’t recommend them more!

  • LRC Editor's Choice

    Awesome shoe, Hoka Mach 5

    20 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    8.0
    Cushioning
    7.0
    Durability
    4.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    9.0

    This shoe is awesome, it is very light for the amount that you get in the shoe. A pretty roomy toebox with an amazing lockdown with the laces and a super comfortable and breathable upper.

    The ride and energy is outstanding, it has two layers of midsole, the top layer of Profly+ is super bouncy and soft, while the stiffer lower part of the midsole provides a quick snapback and speedy feel to the shoe. I raced it in 5k and 10k and even without a carbon plate I felt propeled and got new PBs more often than not. 

    The outsole though was carved out of the bottom layer of midsole with was grippy but did erode quite quickly.

    It is great value for money as it was only 150 Euros where I live.

    I HAVE NEVER WORKED WITH ANY RUNNING SHOE COMPANIES.

  • LRC Editor's Choice

    Really good daily trainer - it's so good, I have raced in it

    10 miles per week, underpronator, low arches
    Overall
    10.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    10.0
    Appearance
    10.0
    Value
    10.0

    The bright high school kid at the local running shop dragged out several of the usual suspects for me. I was searching for a replacement for one of the 2 road trainers in my rotation. They were all adequate but not ideal, and I was struggling to pick the winner when she suggested an alternative that she used as her daily trainer, the Hoka Mach 5. She explained she prefers it as an all-around asset in her limited closet of shoes. I instantly liked the shoe's name for its Speed Racer reference that she probably wouldn't get and agreed to give it a try. I've worn several different models of Hoka, some like the Speedgoat that I really liked and others like the Bondi that didn't work so well. All have plenty of cushion but sometimes their narrow toe box or bulky if light outsoles made them an adequate but not great fit. The Mach on the other is solidly in my Goldilocks zone for a daily trainer: light but not too minimal, enough but not too much cushion, wide enough not to impinge on my toes, snug enough through the midfoot and heel, and the gentle rocker sole make them bouncy enough for me for racing from 5K up to the marathon. Bonus! They aren't as fast as a plated race shoe, but for my foot they might work better unless it's an 'A' race.

  • Hoka Mach 5

    60 miles per week, overpronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    7.0
    Cushioning
    5.0
    Durability
    7.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    10.0

    Very good shoe that lacks some cushioning but is light and not overly supportive. I am a HS distance runner who runs 65 mpw and have found no issues with it. 

  • Versatile and lightweight

    40 miles per week, underpronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    9.0
    Cushioning
    8.0
    Durability
    6.0
    Appearance
    8.0
    Value
    6.0

    Fits true to size. Laces were long which was a big plus, and the heel lock was better than a lot of other shoes I’ve worn. They had enough cushion to work for recovery and easy miles, but were lightweight and firm enough for faster work. Paces up to 5:20/mi felt comfortable in it, and paces as slow as 8:30 felt fine as well. I’ve had three pairs, one lasted 400mi before feeling a bit flat, the other two lasted around 200mi. I now rotate them all. Pretty solid overall, maybe not worth $140 though. 

  • Best All-Round Shoe on the Market

    40 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    9.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    8.0
    Durability
    8.0
    Appearance
    7.0
    Value
    9.0

    I used this shoe as a daily trainer for a little over 2 months. Loved how it could keep up on tempo, easy, and long runs. Got a little over 400 miles in before I retired them and the midsole weakened. It is a super light shoe that is on the faster side of daily trainers. Definetely one of my favorite shoes to use.

  • Most comfortable but look huge!

    10 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    8.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    8.0
    Durability
    5.0
    Appearance
    3.0
    Value
    7.0

    The Mach 5's are about the most comfortable shoe I have had. They are good for running easy and also good for picking up the pace so perfect for interval sessions with easy jogs for recovery. There was an issue with the insole however. It is thin and removable. There is a flaw with the way the holes are aligned and when warm, they formed a crease, which was quite uncomfortable. I resolved the issue with new insoles.

  • Best Daily Trainer for Middle Distance Runners and Mid-Forefoot Strikers

    35 miles per week, neutral pronator, medium arches
    Overall
    10.0
    Comfort
    10.0
    Cushioning
    10.0
    Durability
    9.0
    Appearance
    10.0
    Value
    10.0

    Such a fun shoe! Good for long runs and 27 second 200s! Perfect shoe!!