RRW: Jenny Simpson, Nick Willis Continue Winning Ways at New Balance Fifth Avenue Mile

By Rich Sands, @sands
(c) 2019 Race Results Weekly

NEW YORK (08-Sep) -– Jenny Simpson and Nick Wills extended their dominance at the New Balance Fifth Avenue Mile here today, earning hard-fought wins in close battles down the famed Manhattan roadway. For Simpson, it was a record-extending eighth overall (and seventh consecutive) title in the event, while Willis broke the record for most men’s victories with his fifth win.  A record 9172 runners completed what was the 39th edition of the race, according to race founders and organizers New York Road Runners.

Jenny Simpson edges Elinor Purrier to win the 39th New Balance Fifth Avenue Mile in 3:51.7 (photo by Jane Monti for Race Results Weekly)

Article continues below player

Under sunny skies with warm temperatures (74F/23C), the women’s field set off at an aggressive tempo. Simpson, who lives and trains in Boulder, Colo., was among the early leaders on the opening downhill quarter mile, with New Balance teammate Elinor Purrier and Jessica Judd of Great Britain beside her. After an uphill second quarter mile, Simpson had a slight lead and continued to press the pace. Purrier, Judd and American Nikki Hiltz were on her heels at the front of a tightly bunched pack.

As the course began to descend, the Boston-based Purrier pushed to the lead and ran side-by-side with Simpson. Finally, with about 300 meters to go, the second-year professional out of the University of New Hampshire opened up a slight gap. But Simpson never ceded more than a few inches and her familiarity with the uneven terrain of Fifth Avenue was the deciding factor as she edged ahead to hit the tape in 4:16.1. That cut half a second off the event record she set in 2017 and shared with PattiSue Plumer.

“To set a course record is such a huge point of pride for me,” Simpson told Race Results Weekly. “To think that at this point in my career I’m still running personal bests, I am really proud of that.”

Purrier was just one-tenth of a second behind, while Rebecca Mehra (4:22.0) of Bend, Ore., was well back in third and Hiltz (4:25.4) and Judd (4:26.2) rounded out the top five. In addition to taking home US $5000 for the victory, Simpson also earned a $1000 bonus for leading the field at the halfway point.

Simpson scored her first Fifth Avenue Mile title back in 2011 and has now won seven years a row since 2013. She credits that experience for helping her navigate the bumpy final stretch.

“The road is really rough and so learning how to stay on your feet is a big part of this race,” she said. “But that will to win is the biggest thing in the last 150 meters. You have to look up at that finish and say that no matter what it takes I have to get there first.”

The 2016 Olympic bronze medalist in the 1500 meters, Simpson will soon head to Doha, Qatar, to compete in the IAAF World Championships, which begin later this month. She previously won a world title in 2011 and picked up silver in 2013 and 2017.

Purrier, the 2018 NCAA Indoor champion in the indoor mile, is joining Simpson on Team USA in Doha, though she will be racing the 5000 meters. She admitted that Simpson’s reputation in this event was on her mind.

“It’s a little intimidating, I’m not gonna lie,” she said. “But I try not to let that get in my head and just give myself a chance and put myself there.”

Astonishingly, the men’s race was even closer. After Sam Parsons bolted to the lead on the climb to the half-mile mark (smiling as he passed that stage, knowing he was en route to collecting the halfway bonus for the second year in a row), the field patiently reeled him in. With a quarter mile to go, a massive pack prepared for a closing sprint.

Just under 300 meters from the tape, Chris O’Hare of Great Britain bolted ahead and quickly opened up a 10-meter gap. For a while it appeared that he’d startled his rivals just enough to make it home first. But Sam Prakel of the U.S. managed to close the gap with less than a 100 meters to go. Moments later, Willis, who had been lurking several strides behind, came flying through on the right-hand side of the roadway, sneaking into the picture. Dipping at the tape like a sprinter, the New Zealand native, who lives in Ann Arbor, Mich., made slight contact with O’Hare and won by inches, with both athletes clocking 3:51.7.

“With 40 meters to go I hit a manhole cover and I lost my momentum a little bit and I thought that must be it,” said Willis, a two-time Olympic medalist, who previously won this event in 2008, ’13, ’15 and ’17. “I did just enough to get my chest in front of his.”

Prakel was just a tenth of a second behind in third, while Australian Morgan McDonald (3:52.8) and American Andy Bayer (3:53.2) finished fourth and fifth. By breaking 4:00 in 10th place, Parsons (3:55.0) qualified for the halfway leader bonus.

Though Willis already shared the record for most men’s wins on Fifth Avenue (with Isaac Viciosa of Spain), he was considered an underdog this time around. At age 36, he’s struggled in his racing this season, and won’t know for sure if he’s made it into the World Championships field until later this week. He also aims to compete at the 2020 Olympics in Tokyo.

“It’s been a challenging season for me and it was hard to stay motivated,” he admitted. “There were several times this year where I was like, is it really worth the sacrificing anymore. But today actually says that it is and it’s going to give me another lease on life for Tokyo, 11 months from now.”

Men’s Pro Results
1 1 Nick Willis 36 Ann Arbor MI NZL adidas 03:51.7
2 3 Chris O’Hare 28 Tulsa OK GBR adidas 03:51.7
3 6 Sam Prakel 24 Versailles OH USA adidas 03:51.8
4 12 Morgan McDonald 23 Madison WI AUS Under Armour 03:52.8
5 8 Andy Bayer 29 Bloomington IN USA NIKE 03:53.2
6 10 Robert Domanic 24 Boston MA USA Reebok 03:53.2
7 11 Julian Oakley 26 Providence RI NZL Ocean State Athletic Club 03:53.3
8 16 Tripp Hurt 26 Boulder CO USA 03:53.6
9 15 Riley Masters 29 Boulder CO USA NIKE 03:54.7
10 17 Sam Parsons 25 Boulder CO GER adidas 03:55.0
11 5 Henry Wynne 24 Seattle WA USA Brooks Beasts 03:56.0
12 20 Jordan Mann 26 Providence RI USA Ocean State Athletic Club 03:56.0
13 19 David Ribich 23 Seattle WA USA Brooks Beasts 03:56.6
14 14 Graham Crawford 26 Burlington NC USA HOKA ONE ONE NJ-NY Track Club 03:56.9
15 18 Robert Napolitano 24 Manhattan NY USA HOKA ONE ONE NJ-NY Track Club 03:57.3
16 9 Izaic Yorks 25 Seattle WA USA Brooks Beasts 03:57.4
17 2 Edward Cheserek 25 Flagstaff AZ KEN Skechers Performance 03:58.5
18 7 Pat Casey 29 Flagstaff AZ USA Under Armour 03:58.8
19 4 Johnny Gregorek 27 Tarrytown NY USA ASICS 04:01.7

Women’s Pro Results
1 30 Jenny Simpson 33 Boulder CO USA New Balance 04:16.2
2 32 Elinor Purrier 24 Boston MA USA New Balance 04:16.2
3 44 Rebecca Mehra 24 Bend OR USA Oiselle 04:22.0
4 31 Nikki Hiltz 24 San Diego CA USA adidas Mission AC 04:25.4
5 36 Jessica Judd 24 Canvey Island Es GBR Adidas 04:26.2
6 35 Emily Lipari 26 Washington DC USA adidas Mission AC 04:27.1
7 48 Heather Kampf 32 Minneapolis MN USA ASICS 04:27.2
8 50 Amy-Eloise Neale 24 Charlottesville VA GBR 04:27.3
9 45 Lianne Farber 27 Brighton MA USA New Balance 04:28.2
10 42 Katrina Coogan 25 Boston MA USA New Balance 04:28.3
11 40 Heidi See 30 San Diego CA AUS adidas Mission AC 04:29.4
12 37 Heather MacLean 24 Boston MA USA New Balance 04:30.3
13 41 Megan Mansy 25 Dobbs Ferry NY USA HOKA ONE ONE NJ-NY Track Club 04:31.0
14 51 Mariah Kelly 28 Victoria BC CAN New Balance 04:31.3
15 43 Angel Piccirillo 25 Villanova PA USA Juventis TC 04:32.1
16 49 Allie Ostrander 22 Seattle WA USA Brooks Beasts 04:33.5
17 38 Eleanor Fulton 26 Portland OR USA 04:35.0
18 34 Lauren Johnson 32 Boston MA USA Boston Athletic Association 04:36.6
19 47 Therese Haiss 24 San Diego CA USA adidas Mission AC 04:44.4
20 46 Dana Giordano 25 Boston MA USA Boston Athletic Association 04:50.5

*Official 2019 Fifth Avenue Mile Thread: Jenny Simpson wins 8th title in event record 4:16.2