Galen Rupp's triumphant debut at the Twilight Meet in Eugene last week has the running world excited - and why not? The 19 year old neo-Duck knocked 15 seconds off Rudy Chapa's 10k AJR set in 1976, ran an incredible negative split, and threw off a sub 14:00 final 5k in a phenomenal solo flight finish.
But... as promising as this run was and as magnificent an accomplishment as it is, Rupp will have to run even faster in the Pac 10 Championships later this month in Eugene to be the greatest American Junior runner at this distance. Gerry Lindgren's 27:11.6 6 mile AJR set at the AAU Nationals in 1965 in San Diego is still the high bar standard for 10k and 6 miles both in terms of raw times and in terms of comparative accomplishment.
Raw times? Rupp's 28:15 translates to ~ 27:18 6 mile on conversion. Forgive me for thinking that they probably clocked this at Hayward Field and neglected it in the press release because it was not a better mark than Lindgren's run 40 years ago.
Comparative accomplishment? Rupp ran at twilight. Lindgren ran in the heat of the day (the Snell-Ryun match race was the feature in San Diego and run in the cool of evening). Rupp ran at Hayward Field in front of an adoring audience. Lindgren was running despite an NCAA ban on AAU competition and thought that a car back firing during the race was someone shooting at him (if you think this is indicative of Lindgren's fragile mental condition, read reports of the times...). Rupp's race was rabbitted. Lindgren was in a take-no-prisoners war with Billy Mills. Rupp enjoys the finest coaching, facilities, and support of any runner his age in history. Lindgren because of NCAA rules of the time had effectively "taken the year off" from competition because he was ineligible to run as a freshman at WSU. Rupp ran his race on the fastest running surface in the world. The "new synthetic" San Diego track was so hard that Mills said he had blood blisters in his feet after three miles. Shoes? Only runners of the time can tell you the difference between Nike track spikes now and Dassler Brothers spikes of forty years ago.
Yet Lindgren not only ran faster than Rupp in absolute terms, he broke the standing 6 mile WORLD record and the 10k mark set by Ron Clarke on conversion. That they didn't actually run a 10k was not Lindgren or Mills' fault. Mills told me that Col. Don Hull the meet organizer in San Diego had promised him that there would be a 10k finish line and clock in his attempt to be the first man under 28:00 for that distance. Hall balked the day of the event which almost caused Mills to withdraw except for the remarkable pressure Lindgren had endured to come to San Diego despite the NCAA ban. (Lindgren does not remember this; he was invited to the AAU meet, he says, and he accepted in order to qualify for the US/USSR meet in Kiev that year - and then was put under siege by the NCAA.)
Galen Rupp is a great runner and I will be cheering for him to beat Lindgren's 6mile/10k on conversion real AJR in the months he has left as a Junior Runner. Gerry Lindgren, too, is a man of many failings and a tortured personal history that many people cannot applaud as a runner because they cannot see past the man.
But, let's face facts. Lindgren's Junior records in absolute and comparative terms dwarf Rupp's accomplishments to date. This should not make one think less of Rupp and his coaches. It should only clarify the enormity of Lindgren's accomplishments 40 years ago. Rupp may very well win a bunch of NCAA crowns and set records. Until he does, though, Lindgren's 11 of a possible 12 NCAA national titles, world record at 6 miles, and American records in the 3 mile, 5k, and 6 miles are the collegiate and Junior gold standard. I doubt very much we'll ever see a runner of his merits again.
E. Garry Hill at T&FNews pulled this out of his files to describe what Lindgren's run in San Diego meant in the war between the NCAA & AAU:
Cordner Nelson wrote in the next issue of the magazine, >
Hill asks in an aside about the observation that Lindgren was "on his way to becoming the greatest runner in the history of the world" that we should "consider that statement with Lindgren's place in history relative to Rupp." Yes, indeed.
In the year that Rupp has "broken" two of Lindgren's marks (at least in the popular mind, if his races at 5k as a HS runner and as a Junior runner at 10k really do not hold up to anything but time comparisons), Rupp could actually meet the man himself in Eugene the weekend of the Pre Classic.
http://www.letsrun.com/forum/flat_read.php?thread=859311
Here's hoping Salazar or UO or Nike have the sense of history and respect to make such a meeting happen.