I say Luke.
Thoughts?
I say Luke.
Thoughts?
But Anakin has "dad strength" though..
At their peak? Luke. Remember, Anakin got beat down by Obi-Wan in Episode 3 and almost again in Episode 4. Luke beatdown Anakin in 6.
Luke managed to use the dark side while Anakin succumbed to it.
Luke pwnd Anakin
Luke was more powerful. Anakin had more potential.
Hard work beats talent when talent doesn't work
Anakin at his peak when he wasn't questioning the dark side of the force would have crushed Luke. Luke beat Anakon when Anakin was struggling with the force and bit decrepit. He also gave mercy to Luke and might have lost on purpose
Anakin would have also crushed Obi Wan at his peak
Jar Jar Binks was able to use the force and was originally intended to be a Jedi. It's a shame that they never developed him. He would have been a drunken master with yoga-like reflexes. He would have crushed Luke if and when he went to the dark side
Pappy435 wrote:
Luke was more powerful. Anakin had more potential.
Hard work beats talent when talent doesn't work
Wait a second. Didn't Anakin train for several years with Obi-Wan? And didn't Luke's training consist of a day or two with Yoda in a swamp?
Luke won because he was white. Anakin lost because some ho drove him crazy and he was a black thug. Racist, stupid movies.
Anakin was more powerful, but the old, racist, white man kept him down. Luke did almost nothing, and is somehow the savior of the galaxy. Get real.
Yoda.
Josh Hamilton's Addiction wrote:
I say Luke.
Thoughts?
Obi Ewok wrote:
Anakin at his peak when he wasn't questioning the dark side of the force would have crushed Luke. Luke beat Anakon when Anakin was struggling with the force and bit decrepit. He also gave mercy to Luke and might have lost on purpose
Anakin would have also crushed Obi Wan at his peak
Did you not read above? A poster already pointed out that Obi Wan easily beat Anakin when Anakin was turning to the dark side.
Then Obi Wan was beating him before letting Darth Vader/Anakin kill him to help Luke and gang escape. In that scene, he had 20 years of practicing the dark side and Obi Wan was fairly old, Anakin was at his peak and Obi Wan was not, yet he still was beating him.
Obi-wan never "easily" beat Anakin. It is well known that Anakin would of won that fight if it kept going, but Obi-wan got the high ground, using Anakin arrogance against him. If Anakin kept a level head and took it slow he would've eventually overpowered Obi-wan. Even than Obi-wan form 3 was damn near impenetrable. He had perfect defense being one of the only Jedi's that could fight against Grievous. Vader was held back due to his robotic body, and wanting to overthrow the Palps. If Anakin had fought Luke during using both of them from their last movie at that point Anakin would over power luke with his crushing vanguard, and use of the force.
Definitely Anakin. He impregnated foxy Natalie Portman's character so hard she had twins.
Luke was a whiney brat who couldn't get a girl interested in him besides his own sister.
I live under a bridge wrote:
Definitely Anakin. He impregnated foxy Natalie Portman's character so hard she had twins.
Luke was a whiney brat who couldn't get a girl interested in him besides his own sister.
Cute Natalie Portman character also fell for that whiny emo kid Zach Braff played in Garden State, so I wouldn't put too much stock in the boning Natalie Portman metric.
I thought it was Portmyn? wrote:
I live under a bridge wrote:
Definitely Anakin. He impregnated foxy Natalie Portman's character so hard she had twins.
Luke was a whiney brat who couldn't get a girl interested in him besides his own sister.
Cute Natalie Portman character also fell for that whiny emo kid Zach Braff played in Garden State, so I wouldn't put too much stock in the boning Natalie Portman metric.
Hell, depending on whose story you believe, Anakin was getting Moby’s sloppy seconds.
Daddy’s belt
UsedToBeKnowItAll wrote:
Pappy435 wrote:
Luke was more powerful. Anakin had more potential.
Hard work beats talent when talent doesn't work
Wait a second. Didn't Anakin train for several years with Obi-Wan? And didn't Luke's training consist of a day or two with Yoda in a swamp?
Luke won because he was white. Anakin lost because some ho drove him crazy and he was a black thug. Racist, stupid movies.
Anakin was more powerful, but the old, racist, white man kept him down. Luke did almost nothing, and is somehow the savior of the galaxy. Get real.
Even in jest, some always see things in terms of race.
Obi Ewok wrote:
Luke beat Anakon when Anakin was struggling with the force and bit decrepit. He also gave mercy to Luke and might have lost on purpose
His plan was for Luke to refuse to kill him and kill the emperor instead. But he was too weak to kill the emperor.
Remember that! Sidious was the most powerful of all, by far. Beat down Yoda with a cackling laugh. Pretended not to be able to beat down Mace Windu in order to get Anakin to join the "dark" side, which he had explained was really the "whole force" side. Sacrificed his face to end corruption and stabilize the galaxy, as he promised.
I thought it was Portmyn? wrote:
I live under a bridge wrote:
Definitely Anakin. He impregnated foxy Natalie Portman's character so hard she had twins.
Luke was a whiney brat who couldn't get a girl interested in him besides his own sister.
Cute Natalie Portman character also fell for that whiny emo kid Zach Braff played in Garden State, so I wouldn't put too much stock in the boning Natalie Portman metric.
This has to be the POD with the extra super POD for immediate comeback
Moby’s Dick wrote:
I thought it was Portmyn? wrote:
Cute Natalie Portman character also fell for that whiny emo kid Zach Braff played in Garden State, so I wouldn't put too much stock in the boning Natalie Portman metric.
Hell, depending on whose story you believe, Anakin was getting Moby’s sloppy seconds.
She also fell for Danny MF McBride in Your Highness. Damn near broke my heart too.