I have two options. I can go to school A or school B. Both are roughly equal academically. School A has a much better running program and I think I'll fit in better with the team and coach, but it costs about $4k more a year than school B. Money isn't super tight, but I'll likely be pulling out some loans before I finish school. How much is running worth? What would you do?
I wish I would have chosen a school with a better running program. You've already answered both big questions: academics and finances. I always look back with a bit of regret, wishing that I would have had a better coach, faster teammates, better competition, etc. At the end of the day, your collegiate running will be something you hold on forever. The price is not just for that running, but the memories of awesomeness that you'll rehash over countless bottles of a nice stout brew.
Besides, 4K in loans per year is nothing. Try 100K then get back to me. Go to school A so you can run fast you pansy.
I'd go to the better running school.