Note that this article is cosigned by Jenny Meadows who said she provided info for it, so we can assume the timeline to be correct.
August 2024 - Post-Olympic final: "minor knee injury" - shuts down season
Feb 2025 - Pulls out of Keely Klassic due to GRADE THREE left hamstring tear, whilst being in indoor WR shape
May 2025 - According to this article, she has ANOTHER GRADE THREE TEAR.
July-August 2025 - Pulls out of several meets to postpone her opener, comes back after over a year without a race and drops a 1:54.75.
A grade 3 tear is a complete rupture. Gabby Thomas had a grade 2 (less severe) tear before USAs in 2022 and didn't even make the team, which "only" required a 22 flat (which is certainly no 1:54.7). How was Keely able to:
a) Go from a knee injury to WR shape from August 2024 - Feb 2025
b) Completely tear her hamstring TWICE then rehab and be in "close to WR shape" (her coach's words) from May - August 2025?
If no-one here is willing to admit that the exact same set of circumstances for Mary Moraa or any other non-western athlete would result in relentless suspicion from this very forum, then I do not think we are being very honest.
Furthermore, is the concept of "race sharpness" something that doesn't apply to Keely? Her past 2 seasons were opened in 1:55 as well, the 2024 one also being off the back of an injury. How is she getting in so much high quality training whilst noticeably injured? Athing Mu said she is currently fit, yet was only able to open to a 2:03 and after injuring her hamstring last year was barely in 1:59 shape, despite arguably being more talented (or at least equally so) than Keely and having everything on the line (Olympic team). A lot is made of the fact that Bobby is coaching her (doping allegations) yet Keely's profile has undoubtedly been more dubious than Mu's, even going back to teenage years.
It appears to me that at the very least her injury stories are heavily exaggerated. The possibility of her having "help" to rehab these so fast time and time again, or these stories just being coverups definitely seems more than 0. Most athletes with these injuries are out for at least a season and sometimes aren't the same after. I'm to believe she had 2 grade 3 tears plus a knee injury and is in WR shape? Please let me know how this makes any sense. Mind you, I've seen people on this forum suspicious of Jonah Koech for taking less time off than this due to a tight hamstring. This is two grade three tears.
