I am not disagreeing with what you've written, but hear me out... I ran for a Nike sponsored school in college, and have trained in Pegasus for nearly my entire life (I am 40). I have been so dissatisfied with the Pegs in recent years, and have tried the Vomero, the Infinity RN, and even some of the trail shoes just to try to find my new "go to" in the Nike lineup. I don't like any of them. They just aren't working for me, and I am about a loyal as a customer can be...
Recently, I have seen a lot of younger pro athletes go to NB, and decided to check out their shoes. I would not have done this if it weren't for Valby and Blanks (at the time, he was just NIL). I just figured they have to have some decent shoes if those two are running for NB. Turns out I really, really like the Rebel as a daily trainer. It doesn't last as long as I'd like, but the shoe itself is fantastic. Great for long runs but also allows me to speed it up if I am feeling decent.
So while everyone is different, I think they helped convert me over to NB, at least for now. Maybe there are more of me out there...?