Don't be so smug. I was merely asking based on the sentence you wrote. Transfers come from JUCOs and NAIA and D2 also. You made it sound like it was the list of ranked returners from last year.
And further... you don't think that pretty much every top distance runner, attempts to run a fast 5k during track season...
Yeah sure some specialize in other events but almost every runner who is a serious distance runner and a serious threat in cross country is going to try to lay down a fast 5k
And out of every one of those runners that is returning to college... six of the top 12 times were done by NC State runners
There are different opinions on the top 10 or top 30 from "professionals" such as the Stride Report and Flotrack.....From what I can tell from last year, the Wood report is no better, no worse than other predictors in aggregate....some hits, some misses. Last year I believe in a pre Nats prediction he had 3 BYU runners in top 10 (and BYU winning)......only Orton made top 10 and the 3rd runner finished 38th. I don't mean to pick on him, but noone is perfect, or even close to perfect. But no, not "every runner who is a serious distance runner and a serious threat in cross country" is going to try to lay down a fast 5k.....people recover from injuries, focus on 1500 or steeple...etc. Larkin and Van Camp beat 4 NC St runners in 5K yet are ranked lower than all 4?
I just read through this thread. Is there any chance that ezrun is semihaze? Semihase seems to be MIA and both seem to have the same level of obsession with the NC State women...
I read through it too. Seems like the guys talking sense and people are making moronic rebuttals that are completely idiotic. And then trying to act above it all when he calls them out and remarks that they're kind of being dopey. And then ask to not use insults while insulting the guy
If you go through their 5K times you literally see an ALMOST straight progression of order of finish and personal bests REPEAT ALMOST
Orton 1514
Mercy 1517
Roe 1525
Chmiel 1527
Etc...
There's a few outliers logue is only a 1540 runner while denner is 1525... hasz 1535 I think
But the basic point is there's a strong correlation between 5K track times and cross country performance
Do you realize the first time Taylor Roe ran a 5,000 was this past Spring ie after she had finished 2nd, then 5th in NCAA XC? Prior 5,000 times can be a guide, but there are more potential top finishers than just that. And people improve, for example, Tuohy and Valby who have now run 15:15 and 15:20 but only finished 15th and 27th last year. 5 NC St in top 10 seems way out there to me.
If you go through their 5K times you literally see an ALMOST straight progression of order of finish and personal bests REPEAT ALMOST
Orton 1514
Mercy 1517
Roe 1525
Chmiel 1527
Etc...
There's a few outliers logue is only a 1540 runner while denner is 1525... hasz 1535 I think
But the basic point is there's a strong correlation between 5K track times and cross country performance
Do you realize the first time Taylor Roe ran a 5,000 was this past Spring ie after she had finished 2nd, then 5th in NCAA XC? Prior 5,000 times can be a guide, but there are more potential top finishers than just that. And people improve, for example, Tuohy and Valby who have now run 15:15 and 15:20 but only finished 15th and 27th last year. 5 NC St in top 10 seems way out there to me.
Are you purposely trying to misunderstand what the guy says? I mean I've been reading through and it's kind of obvious he's just saying that it's a bit of an indicator of potential? Anyway I can see why he's getting PO'd because your nitpicking every little detail and missing the obvious truth
I was going to wait till after NC State drops the hammer in a couple of there early meets but I'll just go on record now saying tuohy will win. And NC State will Put 5 in the top 20 and score under 50!
Almost 20 of the top 40 from last year aren't returning! The competition is a lot weaker. And I don't see a whole lot of strength from incoming freshman class. Runners who finished in the twenties and 30s and even 40s last year will have a good chance to push down below 20. And maybe even top 10