Let's look at the 2025 MIAC championship since there is so much "talk" and not enough analysis. The MIAC Men's Rookie of the Year was from St. Olaf. He was also All Conference. A second freshman made runnerup.
I'm lazy so I let ChatGPT do a little work. If you look at the MIAC championship results and only look at the top 20 non-Seniors, St Olaf has 5 runners with St. John's and Macalester tied at 3. If you expancd it to the top 30 non-Seniors, St Olaf has 8 followed by Macalester with 5 and St. John's with 4.
If you just look at the Freshmen results, St Olaf has 3 of the top 10 freshman (1,2, 9). Carleton with 2 at #s 3,5). If you look at the top 30 freshmen, St. Olaf has 6..
Now let's look at the indoor track season for Freshmen. Is the cupboard truly bare? At the MIAC 5000 m Indoor Championship, St. Olaf had 2 fFreshmen finish in the top 12 with one of them in the top 10. No other MIAC freshmen were in the top 20. If you look at just these 2 runners against other freshmen nationally, you will see that they posted the 41st and 43rd fastest times in the nation.
What all this means for the future...who knows? People get injured, sick, or have off days. Can Carleton or some other contender snatch victory away? Of course, that can happen. However, I think it is very difficult to argue that St. Olaf will not be in a strong position over the next 2-3 years to dominate the MIAC and contend on the national stage.
What say you?