I've been on tinder about 10 days and have over 100 matches, and I live in a town of about 50,000 people. There a couple reasons you (and most guys) have no luck on there.
1) Women rate 80% of guys as below average and all think they deserve a guy in the top 10-20%, even women who are 4s and 5s think they deserve an 8 or 9 or 10. I swipe right one just about everyone, and these types will ALWAYS message me first and shoot their shot and let their emotions totally take their feet off the ground. When girls see guys who are 9s, they have a really tough time giving any consideration to guys who are average, even if they are quite average themselves. Women are so driven to get the best guy they can that most will even share one with one or many other women. I have at times had 5 different girlfriends at once. They don't like it, but they tolerate it because it's better than being with a 6. Women are just wired this way.
2) Tinder deliberately made the free version of their app garbage. It was WAY better when it first came out. I couldn't figure out why I was running out of people so quickly all the time, why I wasn't getting anywhere near as many matches as before, etc, and then I paid the subscription for tinder plus or whatever, and suddenly I was seeing way more people and getting way more matches again. Tinder made it so that it hides people from you if you're using the free version and tells you you're out of people even when you're not, and it doesn't show your profile to others anywhere near as much as if you pay. I'm not suggesting you pay, it's dumb, but that might be part of the problem.
Let me know if you want to know more.