As someone who has raced at Wickham twice and against Ridgefield four times this season.........
Wickham is a ridiculously tough course. Bowdoin is also an incredibly tough course. Not a lot of opportunity for that team to run fast. Especially in a year in which NE's was at Wickham.
Their #2 runner (who was #1 at NXR) debuted at the Opens this year due to injury. Raced Opens, NE's, NXR)
Your team times are also off. At NE's, Ridgefield ran a team time of 1:19:5x (not sure exactly, but averaged 15:59). Shattered the Wickham record that they set at State Opens.
They were also uncharacteristically bad at NXR. You would expect Manley (their #2 at NXR) to be like three spots ahead of Lovett, which would have dropped their team score 6 points, and their #5.
More importantly, their typical #4 blew up and finished #6 on their team, dropping their team score by about 40 points (based off of team results, you would have expected him to finish just ahead of their #5)
After all this, they still only missed it by 11 points, and this was the year after losing the best runner in NE. If the At-Large's are based off of best race at NXR, they don't belong in, but if it's based off of best team, they most definetely do.