When a man joined her women’s [track] team, Caroline Hill lost records, privacy, and trust. Now she’s suing the NCAA

If it actually implicated Trump, Biden would’ve released it

As a lifelong Democrat, let me say that I absolutely support this young woman and hope that she wins this suit and has her records restored.

Polling shows that more Democrats agree with me on this than do not.

Instead of tearing each other apart, the smart play is to say, "There is overwhelming bipartisan support for restoring girls' and women's sports as a place of opportunity for biological females."

You are ridiculous and this nazi like hate of one group of people needs to stop!

The article says man, so even their is hate in the title. lets just see how Google AI defines this group of people:

What is a transgender woman" A transgender woman is an individual who was assigned male at birth but identifies as a woman
.
Here's a breakdown of what that means:
Assigned Male at Birth (AMAB): This refers to the sex (male or female) a person was labeled with at birth, usually based on their external genitalia.
Gender Identity: This is a person's internal and deeply held sense of being a man, a woman, both, neither, or somewhere else along the gender spectrum.
Transition: Many transgender people undertake a process called "transition" to align their gender expression and/or body with their gender identity. This can involve social changes (like adopting a new name and pronouns) and/or medical changes (like hormone therapy or surgery).

Let’s take a serious look at women's sports. In 2004 the International Olympic Committee
that oversee sports internationally made it possible for trans women to compete
in women’s sports, across a wide variety of sports, In those years it meant that trans women could compete in the Olympics, World Championships, Road Racing and Cross Country.
Between 2004 and 2022, there were 5 Olympic Games, and 10 World Championship Meets
Unlike other sports people make the most money in track and Field from exposure in the Olympics and World Championships. That is where they get the most endorsements
and of course set records in their events.

If what people who hate trans people say is true about dominance, this would have been fertile grounds for trans women to dominate. There were plenty of opportunities. In a typical track meet there are 18 events, 100m, 200m, 400m, 110 High Hurdles, 400m Intermediate Hurdles, 800m, 1500m, 3,000m steeplechase, 5,000m, 10,000m, marathon, hammer throw, discuss, shot put, long jump, triple jump, high jump, pole vault.

So, for every track Olympic and World Championship level meet there are 18 events or 18 times in that meet for a trans woman to dominate other females. So, any so-called intelligent person here can guess how many of these events over the course of those years were dominated by trans women, since they are supposed to have been so superior. If you participate in these events one can become millionaires, esp. with the Olympics.

Remember they were authorized to compete from 2004 until 2022. That’s 18 events times 5 Olympic games equal 90 and 18 times 10 world Championships is 180. Now that is just talking about gold medals but if we include silver and bronze those numbers equal that is 270 Opportunities during those 5 Olympic games and 540 for 10 World Championships.
Every year track has a regular season like other sports, and they are called Diamond League meets and there are 10 per year. In Diamond league they don’t have as many
events as Olympics, they have about 10 per meet or 180 meets in that 18-year period. 180 times 3 medals per event and another 540 opportunities.

And then there are road races over the 18 year period that was open for trans women to compete in all the big money marathons, ½ marathons, 10k’s and 5k’s etc. , over those 18 years, so that is an untold number of opportunities, but let’s conservatively say 200 race opportunities for superior trans women to beat up on other women and win big money.
In total a quick count gives trans women in track events over a thousand opportunities of 1350 opportunities to compete against and beat cis women and if you include all the road race opportunities over those 18 years we are talking about many thousand opportunities.
And I haven’t included domestic track events like USA Track and Field Championships or Championships held in other countries, and other championships, such as the national and international cross-country races and championships in those 18 years.

Now the question of so-called dominance, in all of those thousands of opportunities and events 2004 until 2022 when trans woman were legally able to compete in these events
against cis women, how many times did they win and or even earn a top 3 medal????????????. You give up, ZERO! ZERO, ZERO, ZERO!

No transgender woman has ever placed in any professional track and field or road race event, ever, not even in the United States or on planet Earth!

How can this be when all of the bigots claim that trans women would dominate but when given the opportunity on the professional level where not only could they dominate but win money, make a living why didn’t that happen?
Have trans women even competed?

A trans woman was good enough to compete in the 2020 marathon Olympic trials. Her
name was Megan Youngren. Now again the claims that trans women would dominate.
IN the Olympic Trials only the top 3 make it to the Olympics. Did Megan make it to the Olympics or was she even close. Nope of course not, she finished near the back in 230th place and nowhere close to making an Olympic team. And it’s funny, but not one right winger complained about Megan Youngren, and until now you never even heard her name.
IN the history of the Olympic Games and remember trans people were able to compete from 2004 until 2022 but in all that time, only one trans person even made it to the Olympics.

She was from New Zealand and her name was Laurel Hubbard In 2020, Hubbard became the first openly transgender woman to compete in the Olympics in weightlifting, although they were allowed to compete since 2004, no one made it.

Now according to the experts maybe trans people are lousy runners, that
could answer the questions as to why in that 18-year period none of them won
anything or even placed, but in weightlifting they should be able to dominate,
RIGHT.

So how did Laurel Hubbard do in the 2020 Olympics. She no-lifted. That means she could not even lift the opening weight. She could not beat any of the women

olympics.com

Laurel Hubbard crashes out of Olympic weightlifting final

Transgender weightlifter Laurel Hubbard saw her Olympic dream come to a premature end after three failed attempts in the opening phase, the snatch

Open link

.

There has not been one world class transgender runner on planet earth who could even compete with cis women in Olympic or World Championship or Road Racing at the professional level. It has just never happened at the professional level, and I reiterate, they were authorized from 2004 until 2022 when Seb Coe banned them. Which is funny
because he literally banned something that never existed at the professional
level and that being a world class transgender female runner.

So, I asked where did all the uproar and hate and hysteria originate and why have trans women not been dominating over a course of 18 years. That is a nice snapshot in time.
Transgender women on hormone replacement therapy have no advantage, and if they did, they would have been piling up medals and money during those years from 2004 until 2022 and they didn’t win a damn thing.

This hatred of trans people makes no more sense than the Nazi’s hate of Jews or White people’s hatred of black people for most of this country’s history or the hatred of gays.

Transgender people a very tiny part of the population are just the latest in a long history of America and its intolerance. It is easy to hate in the absence of research. White people use to say black people were no better than apes and had tails, in Germany it was Jews who was making life worse for everyone or that is what that dictator claimed. The next step or final solution for trans people is genocide!

No one is better than the right wing of America at sowing hate taking an insignificant issue, blowing it up and winning with it. That is right out of Mein Kampf, and it worked very well in 1933 Germany. As for democrats, there are no more of spineless human beings than 99% of democrat politicians. They are cowards to the core and its very hard to beat themselves out of a wet paper bag.

When the leader of 1933 Germany won, many in corporate America stood by him

historycollection.com

10 Famous Companies That Collaborated With Nazi Germany

Khalid Elhassan

Germany's Nazi era was one of the darkest chapters in human history. Fortunately for mankind, Hitler's "Thousand Year Reich" lasted only twelve years before getting stomped into the dirt. Still, Germany was one of the world's...

Open link

and people of good will hid, the same things democrats are doing now!

The total elimination of trans people in this country is the final step they will try, and democrats will do nothing! They say there are almost a million trans people in the
United States, well that many were eliminated in just 90 days in Rwanda!

But the people of this site and those in power in Washington will continue to stoke the seeds of fear, its trans people making your bill increase, its trans people as
to why you lost your job, its trans people making the cost of food, gas and
electricity increase, it’s trans people this, its trans people that………………………..

Until there are no more trans people and your life will improve. We’ve seen this logic in history before and as they say history repeats itself!

Nobody is reading that propaganda.

I skeptical you are capable of reading.

Why do you think everything is about politics?

The "triple truth" guy could be just a troll who is getting joy out of enraging other posters.

He could be a garden variety misogynist who is looking for every opportunity to bash women.

Or he could be a rightwing cultural warrior who wants to make "the left" look bad.

It's understandable that a transgender woman who loves track would want to continue competing in the sport she loves.

It is understandable that she would want to compete with women, as she identifies as a woman.

It is also obvious that transgender women have a significant advantage over women when it comes to sports. If there was clearly no advantage post transitioning, this wouldn't (shouldn't) be an issue. Unfortunately, that's not the case. This advantage is leaps and bounds ahead of any normal within-sex variability.

As a result, I feel it's prudent to not allow transgender women to compete in the women's division. I can understand why this would upset transgender women and feel unfair. Unfortunately, it's necessary to maintain the protected class of women's sport.

I think the above argument can be made without vitriol and without insulting the athlete in question. LetsRun threads on these topics unfortunately fall well short in this area.

Oh, the irony.

"I skeptical..."

What is this "Assigned x at birth" crap?

Do babies also get "assigned" an age of 0?

Was this baby "assigned" a penis?

Your religion and culture worships pedophilia and child sacrifice. You aren’t fooling anyone nation wrecker.

I read it and do not agree with him.

I accept Schreiner as a woman, but I don't think she should be allowed to compete against cis women. Both statements can be true.

I also think she is an insufferable egocentric narcissist. But that's not because she is trans.

This is rich. Demonstrably the biggest misogynist on the board accusing someone else of such. This freak hates real women and has a strange fixation on children. Look at his posts.

Tell us what you think is the "significant advantage" this athlete has over cis women.

She ran 4:40 (1600) /10:07 (3200) as an 11th grader. After years of hormone replacement therapy (and gender affirming surgery), she ran 11:33 (3000) /2010 (5000) as a college senior. All those times are comparable in the World Athletics scoring tables. (And most people run faster as a college senior than they did in 11th grade, if they continue to train.)

athletic.net

Evelyn Parts - MD Track and Field Bio

Evelyn Parts - MD Track and Field results and photos on Athletic.net

Open link

https://www.tfrrs.org/athletes/8599054/Swarthmore/Evie_Parts.html

You need to take a biology class. Your sex is not determined at birth. It’s determined at conception. Sex cannot be changed with surgery, hair style or clothing choices.

What an awful makeover. He was hot as a guy and as a woman he is ginger wispy haired bespectacled NERD who looks old enough to be most collegiates' parental influence.

This person was assigned male before birth. Her parents were expecting a baby boy and was surprised to find the baby had no penis.

She was reassigned female at birth. She was raised as a girl and identifies herself as a woman.

You are the one who needs to take a biology class. Your high school class may not tell you everything you need to know.

"Sure he stole your watch, but it wasn't that nice a watch anyway, so just shut up and take it."

Your own opinion about the value of what was lost doesn't change whether the whole thing is right or wrong.

Good for her