Hats off to Tuohy. She just 3 peated and did it in amazing fashion. Had two women run her down and pull just about even with 200 meters to go but she found a way to hold them off.
But logic says Young has to be considered the bigger prospect.
1) Young nearly 15 seconds better than the next best US HSer right now.
2) Tuohy had 2 other girls right behind her within 1 second.
3) Tuohy isn't as a good as she was last year according to the Tully speed ratings. Her best mark this year would have been her #6 from last year.
When you combine those facts with all of the other struggles that HS girls phenoms have had over the years, I think Young is clearly the bigger prospect.
PS. Please remember you are talking about real human beings in this thread.